General Question

prolificus's avatar

For those who finished their master's thesis, how did you do it (specific questions inside)?

Asked by prolificus (6583points) October 12th, 2010

I’ve been postponing the task of starting my thesis. The deadline for completion is a year from now. I’m pursuing a M.Ed. in Multicultural Education, so the thesis needs to have a strong component related to any aspect of multicultural studies.

Here are the specific questions. Please answer one, any, or all:

1. How did you pick a topic?
2. How much time did you spend on the entire project (on average: each day, each week, each month)?
3. How long did it take for you to complete it (how many months)?
4. What was the hardest part about doing your thesis?
5. How did you deal with the hardest part(s) of question 4?
6. What advice would you give to someone trying to figure out a thesis topic?
7. What advice would you give to someone stressing over the idea of starting a thesis?
8. What advice would you give in general regarding the whole process?
9. What organizational tools did you use?
10. What kept you motivated (besides finishing the degree)?

Thanks!

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

11 Answers

wundayatta's avatar

Do they teach you how to come up with a research question? The way most people do it is they have some interest in the field (whatever brought you to multicultural education—perhaps discrimination). Then you read everything you can consume about that area and related areas. You are looking to find out what has already been done.

Along the way, some questions should come into your mind. “I wonder if….” So you research that, to see if anyone has already done that topic. Eventually you’ll find a topic that hasn’t already been done and that might be useful for people to understand.

Another factor that should enter into your decision is what analytical method do you want to use: qualitative or quantitative analysis. What kind of data will you use? Do you need to collect it yourself, or can you use secondary data?

The analytical method and data source should be driven by the research question, but a lot of times people settle on a method they are comfortable with and find a question that requires that method of analysis. So, are you comfortable with statistics? If so, a quantitative research project will be easy. If not, you probably need a qualitative research project.

It’s not that qualitative analysis is easy. Rather, most people have been doing it all their lives. Because they’ve been doing it all their lives, they tend to disrespect it. Statistical analysis seems much sexier because people believe that it’s so hard to understand statistics (it isn’t, but that’s what people believe). Because of that prejudice about qualitative analysis, people think it is much easier than it is. To do it well requires skills that not a lot of people have.

To do your lit review, I would consider using qualitative data analysis software, like Atlas.ti. This will enable you to code your literature and retrieve references to topics of interest more easily. It has the added advantage that if you do decide to do a qualitative research project, you’ve already learned the software.

Think about how you’re going to get the data. Collecting it yourself takes a significant amount of time. You have to design a data collection instrument—qualitative or quantitative, then gather the data (which has lots of problems on its own), and clean it and prep it before you can analyze it. It is far easier to use data that someone else has already collected.

As to getting it done—you’re writing your lit review section as you do the lit review. You’re thinking about data sources, data collection and data analysis methods as you go along, and as you hone in on what you are going to do, you seriously document your thinking on the subject. You may have to do a lit review on methodology, if you are going to put the method to use in a novel way.

As you analyze your data, your analysis and conclusion sections should be coming into focus. And once you’ve got your story pretty much in line, you can think about the limitations and future research sections.

If there is a course in writing a thesis, you should take it. A lot of this stuff will be covered. Or take a data analysis course, if there is one available. Similarly, a methods course would be useful. Do you take these things, or is that only for PhD students?

The closer your topic is to your personal interests, the easier it will be to stay motivated. You’ll really want to know the answer to the question. Hopefully, it will be an important question. That motivates you even more.

To organize yourself you could use project management software. However, unless you’re some kind of geek, that might be biting off more than you can chew. You could use excel to keep track of things, or a calendar program or even a diary of some kind.

That’s enough to get you started, I think. Go forth and prosper! Or something.

janbb's avatar

Mine was for my MLS and involved doing a research guide to a specific topic. I decided to focus on researching small Victorian antiques because I was interested in that period. I had to go to several very specialized collections and write a guide to their blibliographic material. It was fun doing the research work and then a bear of a job to organize and write it up. And that was in pre-PC days.

prolificus's avatar

Thank you @wundayatta. I have taken a course in research / design, a pre-requisite for doing the thesis. I’m aware of the technical aspects of doing a thesis. I’m curious about the practical aspects, as specified in the question. I’m struggling with motivation, stress, and anxiety related to the project. Thanks, though, for the reminder of the technical aspects and for the practical ideas. :)

What led me to study multicultural education was a desire to bridge people groups who are of opposing belief systems. Although I desire reconciliation between all sorts of marginalized groups, I’m specifically drawn to minimizing the opposition between conservative evangelical Christians and people who identify or ally with the LGBTQ community. In the past I’ve been drawn to social work, pastoral ministry, and public school education with the hope of working with marginalized people groups. I feel stuck committing to anything specific because of personal issues (I am gay, I come from a conservative evangelical Christian community, I am trained to be a minister in such community, and I am scared to move forward because of how it will affect my beliefs, my family, my community, etc.) This thesis is more than an academic endeavor for me; it is extremely personal and potentially life-changing.

@janbb – what kept you motivated to organize and write up your research?

janbb's avatar

The desire to get my Master’s degree – and to be done with the project. I think what made it difficult was my struggle with how to organize the material.

In your case, with so much personal stuff in the mix, it might be wise if you can find a mentor or even counselor who can help you sort out some of the issues that arise. It sounds like a very worthy endeavor, though.

BarnacleBill's avatar

My daughter’s program included required classes in methodologies, and she was required to turn in her thesis statement at the beginning of her second year. She had an advisor that she worked with. She had 5 months of research, and a good solid 2 months of writing, and 2 months of editing. Additionally, she had an actual project that applied her research, it is in its final stage of construction this month.

Jeruba's avatar

@prolificus. in view of this sentiment—
I am scared to move forward because of how it will affect my beliefs, my family, my community, etc.
—would it make sense for you to shift your focus a little bit and redefine your topic in a way that isn’t quite so personally threatening to you? A bit more objectivity might benefit your study as well. Perhaps you could move gradually into riskier and more potentially controversial areas once you’ve completed your degree, either in personal projects or in your professional life, without having to face the challenges of a degree program simultaneously with the personal challenges this subject matter will involve for you.

For example, you could study aspects of the subject that would support your future endeavors without trying to tackle big personal issues head on at the same time.

wundayatta's avatar

It seems to me that your interest could be broadly phrased as “is it possible to reconcile marginalized groups?” More specifically, “what is keeping these groups from reconciling?” and “what mechanisms might lead to reconciliation?”

An obvious first step would be a qualitative study that looks at each group’s perceptions of the other and of the issues that separate them. This might seem obvious, but what you’re really looking for are opportunities for reconciliation, so you can ask questions about that.

This is an age old question and there might be lessons to be learned from other conflicts around the world, so you’d want to look at that literature and then contrast that with the way the issue plays out in your particular area of interest.

The thing is that you have the contacts necessary to get people to trust you and answer some pretty serious questions about your issues of interest. That’s an extremely valuable resource. Do people on both sides know who you consort with on the other side?

Another approach might be to look at the impact of being gay on people from the religious community you are from. That might be less dangerous because you aren’t trying to bridge a gap. You are only looking at how the victims feel about it and what has happened to them. This is, of course, a very topical area due to the number of suicides by young gay men that have occurred recently in Mormon communities.

There is also the issue of using therapy to fix gay people back to the desired sexual norm. I don’t know if you could get data on this. You might be able to talk to “therapists” who do this as well as to gay folk who have been through the therapy.

Most of these things are qualitative studies, and I’m not suggesting you do anything. I’m really trying to show you how to think about this stuff—how to ask questions, because that’s what research is all about. You want to minimize opposition between the groups. Well, what do you need to know if you are going to do that? What understanding of the behavior do you need?

That of course depends on what is already known. I kind of have a feeling this area is wide open primarily because of the difficulty in getting people to talk. If you want to do a quantitative study, you’re probably not going to find any data that will help you, but this might be a good place to start looking.

prolificus's avatar

@all – thank you. I have access to resources, it’s just a matter of working up the courage to face my anxiety. I like the ideas of tackling related aspects instead of the BIG personally-threatening topic. I had been toying with some ideas related to the Cass Identity Model, possibly exploring life beyond it.

I agree with the need to have a mentor or counselor to work through personal stuff regarding this thesis.  As a first step I looked into some practical things (I.e. how to pay the tuition to take the thesis class in the Spring). I was happy to find out I’ve the resources in my IRA and can take a loan to repay myself. Yay!  Oh, and I’ve got the support of my partner and friends who are encouraging me and offering to hang at the library with me. This helps!

prolificus's avatar

FYI… I finished my thesis! It’s official! I’ve earned my M.Ed. :)

prolificus's avatar

:) @janbb – thank you

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther