How old are the carbon atoms in our bodies?
Recently I read that carbon atoms on Earth are at least 6 billion years old (note: this question is not about the decay of isotopes).
How good are our astronomical and astrophysical models to determine this value? Could it be something like
6.6 billion years +/- 200 million ?
As far as I know, there are four important factors
1) metallicity of our sun
2) abundance of chemical elements in the universe versus in our solar system
3) shock wave impact mechanism on interstellar clouds of dust and gas
4) time requirements for the formation of our solar system
Many scientists seem to believe that at least two supernovae occurred after the big bang till our solar system was able to form.
What do we know about the timing? And the gaps between the supernovae and the formation of the solar system?
Observing members:
0
Composing members:
0
12 Answers
The “age” of the atoms isn’t very useful because carbon is “recycled” continuously. If an atom “lives” in a C02 molecule and is absorbed by a plant, it begins a new “life” there incorporated into the woody fiber of the plant. With few exceptions, all of our planet’s atoms are fairly stable and persistent; they change form but hang around year after year, with the exception of radioactive materials that are decaying into simpler elements, and the bits of light atmosphere drawn away by the solar wind. Carbon is a good baseline though since it’s simple, stable and visible.
In theory, all the material in the universe has always existed and will always exist even pre/post Big Bang/Big Crunch. Are you asking how long they have existed as Carbon?
@GeorgeGee – No, I’m talking about nucleosynthesis, not molecules carbon might be part of.
@Ame_Evil – Yes. Primordial nucleosynthesis did not produce any carbon as far as I know.
The presence of heavy metallic elements in the Earth would affirm at least one supernova event, but the carbon could predate it by billions of years. It could come from anywhere. I’m a little shaky on this, but can’t the triple-alpha process occur in any star massive enough to produce the reaction as it begins to collapse?
I cant contribute anything intelligent, but I fucking love this question.
Answer this question
This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.