Social Question

skfinkel's avatar

How many of the miners, do you think, will now quit smoking for good?

Asked by skfinkel (13542points) October 13th, 2010

It appears that all were smokers, but obviously had to stop while in the broken mine. Now that they are back on the surface of the earth, do you think any will refrain from smoking? (I think not.)

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

10 Answers

Seek's avatar

I can’t think of any time “Somebody gimme a smoke” would be a more appropriate request than after being buried alive for two months.

zen_'s avatar

^ True dat.

Statistically – they are lifers – maybe a couple will have the brains and willpower to do it.

I did – it wasn’t easy. And I’m a fucking scarecrow.

judochop's avatar

I quit…and I gotta say nothing would make me start faster than being buried alive for two months.

downtide's avatar

No because I doubt that the culture in Chile puts as much pressure on in saying that smoking is dangerous/bad and there’s likely not much encouragement to quit. I bet they all had a cigarette and a beer as soon as they were done with the medical checkups. Hell, if it was me I’d be having a party.

LuckyGuy's avatar

None. Most likely they will never work again . It will be interesting to see how they handle the fame and money that comes with it. I’m betting that they will pick up other “bad” habits along the way. Time (and the press) will tell.

rts486's avatar

I doubt very many of them will quit now they are back on the surface. Interestingly, in Marine Corps boot camp, the recruits are not allowed to smoke for the three months they are there. I would think this forced tobacco free existence for 90 days is sufficient to break the addiction. However, most immediately go back to smoking once they are back in the world.

CMaz's avatar

They will smoke. It is a third world pastime.

Austinlad's avatar

My guess is, they’ll all keep smoking. Ah, but will they mine again?

jca's avatar

@rts486: regarding your answer, don’t the boot campers get days off? and if so (and i’m thinking they would) wouldn’t they have opportunity to do what they wanted, being unsupervised?

rts486's avatar

@ica No, they get no days off. They don’t get any time off. They don’t have access to anything that isn’t issued to them. They are supervised 24/7.

I’m sure some of the more enterprising recruits have figured out a way to get a cigarette, but I’m sure this is very rare.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther