Social Question

ETpro's avatar

How small can the repetitive fractal features of nature get? (Strange Universe Series)

Asked by ETpro (34605points) October 29th, 2010

By now, most of us are familiar with fractal images, a fascinating visual representation of a rather simple mathematical formula developed by Polish Mathematician Benoît Mandelbrot. What many of us may not know is that Mandelbrot first wondered How long is the coast of Great Britain? back in the 1960s. One could easily measure the distance from Brighton Beach in the South to Newcastle on Tyne in the North as the crow flies. But how far is it if you have to walk, and can’t step into water? How far if you aren’t a human capable of jumping any stream smaller than 6 feet across, but instead an ant. What if you are a single-celled organism and must get there on dry land? As we look at a section of natural coast land, we find as we zoom in an ever smaller repeating set of rather similar but incredibly exquisite details. In his search for a mathematical approach to answering his original question about the length of the British Coast, Mandelbrot came to his discovery of the Mandelbrot Set and Fractal Geometry.

Whether we look at incredibly large-scale things such as galactic clusters, and Galaxies; moderate scale such as cloud formations, river deltas, wind-blown dunes and coastal profiles; or small scale such as the edge of a leaf, the folds of the brain, the network of imtermingled neurons, the roots of a tree or the veins and arteries in flesh, we see something very like a fractal. Fractals are mathematical representations which repeat in an infinite regression of similar, but slightly different patterns. As you look closer and closer at the features of a fractal, you see what appears to be an endless regression of repeating symmetry. But how small can that scale go in reality? Photographs or prints of the Mandelbrot Set are limited in their fineness by the size of the grain in the photographic paper or the dots in the print. But how about nature? Are we dealing with something that has a lower limit set by the Planck Constant or some such, or does it indeed not stop, but proceed to infinity in some crossover between the material world of particles and the infinite beneath and beyond the material world?

If you can spare the time, (about 50 minutes for all 6) watch all 6 of the YouTube clips of Arthur C. Clarke’s Fractals. The movie doesn’t answer my question, although Stephen Hawking offers his informed opinion. In the end, it just asks the question in far more eloquently terms than I can put into words.
1 of 6
2 of 6
3 of 6
4 of 6
5 of 6
6 of 6

I cannot tell you why. But after watching the 6 clips above, I just had to listen to Pink Floyd’s Shine on You Crazy Diamond, written as a tribute to their friend gone mad, Syd Barrett. I hadn’t listened to it in years, but somehow it congealed the Mandelbrot Set for me. If you know of a piece of music that works the same for you, I recommend it as a way to let the whole enormity of this Strange Universe sink in.

This is a continuation in the Strange Universe series.
1—How can the most distant quasar be 28 Billion light years away?
2—Can nothing exist without the Universe?
3—How can order emerge out of chaos?
4—Where is the center of the Universe?
5—If CERN proves there are parallel universes, will you move?
6—If the universe expands at faster than the speed of light, does it begin to go back in time?
7—What is the expanding universe expanding into?
8—Big Bang Theory—How can you divide infinity into a single finite whole?
9—How would you answer this speed-of-light question?
10—What happens when the expansion of the Universe reaches the speed of light?
11—What’s your Strange Universe example to illustrate Sir Arthur Eddington’s quote?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

7 Answers

MissA's avatar

Loved the video to Shine On You Crazy Diamond. (Had to get that out of the way!)

I would think that repetitive fractal features would be infinate. It is our way of measuring them that is limited.

Very interesting question.

ratboy's avatar

Benoit Mandelbrot died on October 14.

If space is discrete, having a minimum unit of volume, that unit would appear to be a lower limit for the size of physical entities.

ETpro's avatar

@MissA I’m glad you enjoyed the Pink Floyd piece. It is one of those greats in music in my mind, up there with some of the great classics.

As to the infinity question, it is not us but the Universe doing the measuring in whatever formula it uses to calculate how a dynamical system regresses into finer detail toward a strange attractor that is a fractal. So the question is, does the Universe’s yardstick have a finer mark on than that of the Planck Constant. It may seem a trivial issue on first consideration, but it is truly profound beyond measure. It essentially asks, “Is there a God?”

@ratboy I did not realize that Mandelbrot had died. Such a brilliant mind lost to the world, and it received so little attention. We all must meet our date with the destiny of death, but it is truly sad the 24/7 media saw his passing as of so little interest. I mourn that more than his loss.

Thannks so much for the NPR link. Fascinating.

RealEyesRealizeRealLies's avatar

Did you know that Mandelbrot was an Economist?

Some scary shite folks…

PAH-LEEZE make no comments on this statement, as not to derail the OP… Sorry ET

Crazy Diamond is the Bomb!

And as to the OP, I’ll suggest that the Universe does not measure. But if we measure it, with fractal geometry, we’ll find (and describe) it to be infinitely dense.

ETpro's avatar

@RealEyesRealizeRealLies I am incresingly coming to expect that may be true. It is interesting that if @ratboy‘s link is right, and space is composed of tetrahedrona, they have six sides. A six dimensional Universe is one that works mathematically with string theory.

MissA's avatar

@ETpro I will think about this more…love these types of questions. Thanks for massaging my mind..

ETpro's avatar

@MissA I look forward to hearing your conclusions.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther