@Cirbryn I’d like to address some of your concerns, if I may. The very first thing I’d like to point out is that normally a question that is vague but has prompted a good discussion before we see it will not be removed. In this particular case, there are issues that you are unaware of, and those remain between @Drewseph and the moderation team, unless @Drewseph decides to reveal those issues. Suffice it to say, we did have valid reasons for removing it.
On to the guidelines. I actually agree with you, in that our guidelines could be clearer regarding questions. In fact, this is a current topic of discussion among the mods and the staff. So, yes… they could be better, and I hope they will be in the near future. Even then, though, they probably won’t be perfectly clear, as there will always be judgment calls that must be made. Such is life with human moderation. In our opinion, it beats the heck out of the alternatives.
I also agree with you that edited questions should be reposted at the top of the page, rather than in the spot they originally occupied. Unfortunately, that’s not the way it is. Anyone who has been on Fluther for any length of time knows about this limitation. I’m honestly not sure whether the current set-up is due to technical difficulty or a conscious decision on the part of the site’s owners. In either case, it’s definitely something to consider.
As for removing answers… The guidelines are very clear as to what kinds of answers may be removed. Spam, personal attacks, and poor writing may be removed anywhere on the site. Off-topic and unhelpful answers may be removed in the General Section. If one is willing to post in violation of those guidelines, one must be prepared to have it removed. If an answer is very long, we often do copy and paste it in a PM to the member who wrote it, as a simple courtesy. In addition, any member may contact any moderator and ask for a copy of their removed question or answer, and we will happily provide one.
There are fourteen moderators, from a good cross-section of our membership, so no single mod could go on a power trip or anything silly like that. Anything that isn’t clear cut is discussed and decided on as a team. While there is no formal appeals process, there is a de facto one. Anyone may contact a moderator or myself to discuss why something was removed, and to present a case for why it shouldn’t have been. It doesn’t happen very often, but we do reverse our decisions from time to time. We are, after all, human. We do make mistakes every now and again.