I have had mixed luck. Let me run down the vehicles I have owned.
‘87 Corolla – $500 – 147K : Beat to hell when I got it. I had to replace the exhaust and head gasket on it ($200 total) but required no other major repairs in the two-plus years I had it. I gave this car to my father-in-law after his car died.
‘89 Golf – $350 – 168K : Like any Golf/Jetta of this vintage in New England, the floorboards needed repair, and the rear shocks went out after a few months. Still, that $70 was the only major repair I needed for the year and a half I had that car. It was still running great when I got rid of it, but the body was beginning to rot. Pretty common in NH.
‘90 Civic – Free! – 220K : A hole in the gas tank, and it blew an igniter module ($40 replacement) but it lasted me longer than I thought it would. It snapped it’s timing belt though, and it wasn’t worth repairing.
‘91 Civic Wagon – $500 – ~179K : Awesome car! When the igniter module blew, I took the one out of my old Civic and it ran great for over a year… until the timing belt snapped :(
‘89 Aerostar – $250 – ~182k : Bought in desperation, this rig held only lasted me a few months, but part of that is because I didn’t maintain it. It would’ve required more body work than it was worth to pass another NH inspection, so when the water pump went, I decided to drive it until it died and use the money I saved from not repairing it plus any other savings to replace it. It’s water consumption steadily rose to the point where driving to the store 15 miles away took 2 gallons, and another 3 to get back home. I cracked the engine block almost two months after I thought it would crack, so even though I only had it about six months, I feel I got my money’s worth.
‘94 Corsica – $1,000 – ~98K : The only car I ever owned that had less than 100K miles, and the only one I ever bought from a dealer. It lasted only eight months before the engine underwent sudden catastrophic failure and shot it’s entire supply of antifreeze out the tailpipe.
‘94 Golf – $600 – ~169K : Again with the rusted floorboards ($50 worth of fiberglass). This car was a bitch. In hindsight, I should’ve gone with my gut and not trusted the seller (a local mechanic), but I think that the Better Business Bureau and the law caught up with him for the way he did business.
‘94 Subaru Legacy Wagon LSi – $1,375 – ~158K : Fully loaded, but showing a little age. After $200 for a starter and front half-shaft, this car ran great. The air suspension went out and I drove all winter riding the bumpstops (not good in NH winters!) but drove surprisingly well despite that. When the tax return came in, I dropped the $600 to rip the non-functional air suspension out and convert it to regular (and working!) shocks. This car was sold just before I moved to Seattle.
‘85 Corolla – $300 – ~212K : My current ride. I bought it almost two years ago with four blown shocks, which I got replaced for $500. It stil runs great, especially considering that at least some of the previous owners beat the ever-loving dogshit out of it.
Okay, what can we learn from all this? To start with, the American rigs are a bit fragile, at least the older ones. They’ve improved a bit since, but when you toss in the two transmissions my wife’s Saturn blew, and the trannies that her father blew in a Buick and two Dodges, it’ll be another decade before I trust them.
Second, paying more doesn’t always mean getting more. Sure, the quickest to die were the freebie and the $250 clunker, but the $1000 Corsica didn’t outlast them by much.
Third, beater cars are dicey, but they get the job done and for far less than a “decent” car. For $4,875 purchase price plus another $1,660 in major repairs, I’ve driven for over a decade. Compare that to what my wife’s Saturn cost, she spent double what I did in both areas in just two years!
Fourth, the older Corollas are damn near invincible. Of the eight previous cars I’ve had, only two still ran when I got rid of them; the most expensive and the Corolla. Of the nine on that list, only two of them lasted me more than eighteen months; both of the Corollas. (The Subaru would have, but I sold it and moved before then.).
@worriedguy After the Corsica, my buddy’s V6 Corsica, and that ‘91 Regal my in-laws had, I think you can understand why I am hesitant to agree with you on GM engines. I know that they are better than they used to be, but experience is hard to ignore and set aside.
@cak Even back a decade or two ago, there were some cars that were known to last. Mercedes Benz diesels can go over a million miles, and many have. Dodge Darts and many Toyotas stick around forever too. Still, that was generally true.