@Written You are not compatible with only her. You just want her so badly that you spend all of your waking hours thinking (and obsessing) about her. I’m guessing that you haven’t dated a lot of girls (I would hope not, if you are still in school) and so you really don’t have enough experiences to compare it with. And because you are so focused on this one girl, you probably haven’t had a lot of other close friendships with other girls. You’ve convinced yourself that this one particular girl is the only girl for you and you’ve shut yourself off to other wonderful possibilities. That’s not fair to you, or to your friend, or to other young ladies that might enjoy your company. And I know that you are trying to convince me that she’s not on a pedestal for you, but it is clear to me that she is.
There are tons (millions) of girls out there that desperately want romance and a nice guy. But you have picked a girl that is, in your words “a confused little creature.” I don’t believe that she or the other girls at your school are all that confused. Sometimes young ladies have a difficult time saying out loud what they really want. Females are conditioned from birth to keep quiet and to go along with the flow and they never learn how to say “no” properly or ask for what they really want, because they might get rejected by a boy or punished from their parents. But girls really do know what they want, they might just be too shy or embarrassed to say it out loud. You’d be doing yourself a great service if you got over the notion that girls are “confused little creatures.”
You say that many of your friends have been in the same boat with girls. That’s probably because they chose the girl on her looks and were sorely disappointed when the girl’s personality didn’t measure up. Most young guys choose girls mostly because of their looks and don’t even want a real relationship anyway, they mostly want to get laid. And most girls want friendship and romance, but have a hard time expressing that. And sometimes when they do express that, they get dumped immediately.
You have no idea whether or not you are compatible with other girls, because you aren’t involved with them, you haven’t dated a lot and you aren’t interested in meeting other girls or just hanging out with them as friends, or getting to know them, because you are only thinking about, dreaming about and hoping for this one particular girl to fall in love with you. It’s kind of pretentious to say that you can’t be compatible with other girls. That’s why I keep telling you that your young lady friend is up on a pedestal for you. You can’t/won’t see that there are plenty of other people out there looking for love and friendship. That’s why I said you have on love goggles.
I understand that what you want is quite different from what the average young guy wants. You are looking for friendship and love, and that is what most young ladies are looking for too. I think that you believe that most girls are not looking for kindness and romance, only because you have been hurt before. I’m here to tell you that most girls desperately want love and friendship and romance. But no one can predict with whom they will fall in love. It’s not something that can be forced.
I’ve had plenty of male friends with whom I was very compatible with, but I didn’t feel love in the romantic way for them. And I’ve been on the other side of that coin too, where I felt a clear and obvious attraction for them, but they liked me as a good friend only.
You said that being nice and romantic never got you anywhere. Well it sounds like it got you a really nice friend! But you are discounting the friendship part, because this girl hasn’t told you that she’s in love with you (maybe she is, maybe she isn’t). You also haven’t gotten very far with other girls by being nice and romantic, because you simply haven’t actually attempted that enough times, because you are so focused on this one particular girl. You are still in school, so I would imagine that you haven’t tried the nice and romantic bit on 10 other girls, right? Being nice and romantic is a skill that gets better with practice. Desperation is a trait that often goes along with nice-ness and romance, but desperation is one trait that will drive off females very quickly. A good sense of humor (not sarcasm, though) coupled with friendship and romance is the most luscious combination of traits a young man (or a middle aged man or an old man) can possess. The alternative is that you become a rude, mean douche-bag. Believe me, women of quality do not appreciate that. The example is Charlie Sheen. He’s got a lot of women alright, but they’re hookers and gold diggers.
And I cannot stress highly enough the fact that no one (not me or you or your friend) can make themselves fall in love. But it is still better to be a kind and loving and funny and romantic and decent person (minus the desperation) so when that right one comes along, you can be the best boyfriend/husband you can be, instead of becoming a douche-bag. If sex is the only thing you want, then being a douche-bag is pretty succesful. But I think you want more than that and have more than that to offer.
You should ask another generalized question to all the female flutherites in here to see if they wanted a good guy for a husband or whether they prefer a douche-bag.
I know this is hard and painful and that you have deep feelings for this young lady. But please don’t write off every other female, and don’t even attempt to compare other females to this girl. All girls are different and they also have a lof of wonderful things to give and share with a guy, some of those things you may never know about if you don’t give them a chance too. And most girls (not all) really do want romance and friendship, but you can’t make anyone fall in love with anyone else. Don’t ever make generalizations about people or it will serve to destroy you. Learn now, while you are young, that there are lots and lots and lots of wonderful people who have wonderful qualities to offer and there are many, many people that will be compatible with you, and you may learn things about them and yourself that you never knew existed until you allowed yourself to know.
So go over to your friend’s house with your head held high, let her know how you feel about her and ask her if she feels the same way. If she does, yahoo! If she doesn’t then realize that you are about to start a new journey to find someone who does.
Sorry this is so long, but I felt like I had to give you a mental shake! I could feel you sliding back down into your lovelorn slump. So stand up, and I’ll help to give you a push.