Social Question

ucme's avatar

Music in horror movies, a question [see details]?

Asked by ucme (50047points) April 4th, 2011

Yeah, you know the music that’s meant to heighten suspense at a particularly chilling moment in any horror film? Well my question is this, why is it predominantly bloody screeching violins!?! I mean yeah it serves it’s purpose, but god it grinds my gears! I propose a change of instrument to illustrate the building tension & fear. How about a nice drum roll or maybe even a blast on the old accordian. What alternatives, if any, would you put forward eh? Asked with tongue firmly planted in cheek, so humour as always is encouraged.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

14 Answers

12Oaks's avatar

This would be just what you may want to call an educated guess. The reason so many love the violin, especially the Stradivarius, is the violin, be design, is the instrument which most closely resembles that of the human voice. The sounds are very similiar. That could be the reason why the screeching violins—it sounds more like a human scream than any other instrument could produce.

ucme's avatar

@12Oaks Interesting stuff
@SpatzieLover Nice idea

atomicmonkey's avatar

There is only one answer for this question. The most terrifying, blood curdling instrument in the history of all mankind.

The Bagpipes.

That is all.

ucme's avatar

@atomicmonkey Yeah but you see, those are worse than the bloody violins. Would work well if a strangled cat scene happened to come about.

mazingerz88's avatar

The first things that come to mind are xylophone and human whistling. I’ll give the Oscar to the musical scorer who could pull this off.

aprilsimnel's avatar

Nah. Not violins. It’s the banjo.

Dueling banjos.

Talimze's avatar

The only thing that bothers me about violin music in horror movies is when they are used to make stings to accompany jump scares. That’s not actually scary, people, it’s just cheap.
Much worse than violins is children singing. I suppose it’s supposed to be creepy, but it’s such a cliché at this point that it’s just funny.

I am in favor of piano music. The piano can easily convey any mood. Either that or synth. Synth is always good. Or horrible techno music if you’re Uwe Boll.

downtide's avatar

The best piece of horror-suspense music ever is the low strings (cello? I dunno what it actually is) in Jaws.

Duuuuuuh-duh… duuuuuuuh-duh. Dun-dun-dun-dun Dun-dun-dun-dun Dun-dun-dun-dun…

12Oaks's avatar

@downtide Yes. That would be a Cello. A Cello, for those who don’t know, is basically a big Violin. Rosin the bow, and away you go!

Berserker's avatar

@Talimze Haha nice. Yeah, children singing during any kind of mood is pretty outdone…so much so that often, in horror movies, they have singing children music to a scene, or even a whole movie that has nothing to do with possessed children or any other reason that would be good to have singing children in. Ugh.

I’d love to answer this. But I’ve watched so many horror movies that I have become immunized to the techniques used to attempt and convey moods in most horror movies. I see it coming miles away and it never scares me or makes me sit on the edge of my seat. Since it’s a given that some creepy music will play during an intense moment or some buildup, it’s easy to have it all ruined for you. I find that movies like The Birds or Cookers that don’t use any music to build anything up work much better. Cookers scared the shit out of me.

Music is awesome but it’s also a double edged sword. It conveys emotion very well, but the problem is, I am of the mind that most emotional impact that people derive from many scenes in entertainment only comes from the music and nothing else. Especially not horror movies, where most of it is just funny or unrealistic.
For example, in Final Fantasy VI, which isn’t a movie but still, I always have this tear shedding thing going on when you find out that Nanaki’s father actually stayed behind to protect the village and was turned to stone in the process. Nanaki always thought his dad ran away and abandoned the village when it was under attack, but he actually saved it through sacrifice. I always weep. But I’m pretty it’s just the music. It,s all sad but mixed with a tinge of pride. If I saw it on mute I’d probably be all like, dude, lame.

Where the hell was I going with this…yeah, music creates, but it also steals. If you wonder around in your basement because you heard something, you’ll never hear screeching violins or singing kids, unless you live in a really fucked up neighborhood. So my point is, no matter what kind of music is used, it won’t make anything scarier. There are exceptions…Jeepers Creepers has a pretty freaky fucking music playing in the beginning, with that metal truck…

Anyways, to actually answer the question, I griped about singing children. I still like it though. Same for violins. But what I think would work great to at least change things, would be some very systematic and leveled violent droning. Something that’s barely even music, more like a very music-y sounds effect, like scraping metal or rocks or something. Like thrash metal, only not so hyper. Whether music steals or creates moods, seeing Michael Myers chase some bugger around with music like that would probably be a lot more intense than the famous theme song. Mind you however, I love that theme song to death, and if I ever get married I want that to play.

Actually, Halloween II had one chase scene where my ideal music I described plays…lemme see if i can find it. Aaah there we go. Music like this would be great for intense buildup scenes. Not too hyper, which usually gets on my nerves anyway, and droney and hypnotizing enough to really mess with your nerves.

Also man do I love this scene. It traumatized me as a child.

aprilsimnel's avatar

What gets me is when they play some old-timey record from the 1910s or 1920s on a gramophone in something set today, you know, when the soon-to-be-slashed are exploring some old house and making fun of the old days.

It’s the crackles in the silence of impending doom.

AshlynM's avatar

Piano is good

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther