@gasman
Actually I agree with what you wrote and I think you misinterpreted the intention of my post.
Did you skip over the part where I said that what’s most important is “the effort you made and WHAT YOU LEARNED IN THE COURSE”
What I said would be forgettable five years down the road is “whether you got an A or (just) an A-” I didn’t say you’ll forget what you learned.
I seriously doubt that (without looking it up) that you recall your EXACT SPECIFIC grade for every course you took five years later.
Well, who knows? I suppose you could be some sort of a savant but the majority of people aren’t.
If you noticed in her original question she wanted to raise her grades from A- to an A.
That’s a pretty damn small increment, wouldn’t you agree?
It’s certainly not worth stressing over. That doesnt mean its not worth the effort but if a prof chooses to consider it a half grade point lower in spite of your best effort, developing an ulcer over it isnt worth it.
The EFFORT and WHAT YOU LEARN is what’s still important five years later.
Or do you honestly think any employer is going to give a crap that you only got an A- if your current job performance is great ?
On the flip side, do you honestly think any employer is going to be so stunned by your getting an A in a particular course that he’ll overlook crappy work ?
I don’t see my intent as cynical at all. As a teacher, I’m very well aware of grading not being an exact science and if a particular prof had a cold (or whatever ailment) when doing final grades, that alone could account for an A- rather than an A. That’s life and that’s reality.
My particular approach (and I was dealing with young children) was to reward effort in addition to everything else and my grading reflected that.
Other teachers had a different viewpoint and just graded arbitrarily on test scores to configure the final grade. Every teacher has their own approach to grading. When dealing with SMALL INCREMENTS like half a grade point. it is highly subjective.
All one can do is their best and learn for it’s own sake. That’s what counts five years down the road. NOT half a grade point one way or the other.