Meta Question

tom_g's avatar

I am not entirely sure what the purpose of the NSFW tag is.

Asked by tom_g (16638points) June 14th, 2011

When I am here at work and browsing Fluther (yes, I know – I should be working), I am going through my company’s network. Most companies have the ability to troll for certain words when traffic comes through in order to determine if someone is violating internet policy or if there is something to be concerned about. My understanding is that certain NSFW terms could flag a problem.

So, for example, when I go browse the social questions right now, there is a question that reads:
”(big time NSFW) I have always wonder this, can a woman tell how big her penis would be (if she were male) by the size of her clit?”

Fascinating and all, but I’m pretty sure that adding the NSFW tag does nothing to protect me from clicking on the link to the question. The question itself is NSFW.

Is there a better way we can treat NSFW questions here on fluther? The best option I can think of would be….

Require that the question be phrased as “I have an anatomy question (NSFW)”. Then, the details of the question can go into all kinds of fun stuff.

Note: I could be the only one concerned about this. Plus, I probably shouldn’t be looking at fluther during work anyway.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

12 Answers

jrpowell's avatar

I flagged it for the same reason. People need to stop doing this. This actually happens a lot and the mods will send it to editing. But it shouldn’t be done in the first place.

zenvelo's avatar

That’s a good suggestion. The NSFW tag for me means to be aware that anything goes in the question and in the responses.

My work computer filter is not that granular, but if I had a list of fluther questions open on my computer I would not want someone to see that question.

Jude's avatar

My mistake. You are both right. Being a very descriptive question, yet, having NSFW beside it (in the question) – that’s pointless.

I went ahead and flagged it, as well.

I’m sorry.

tom_g's avatar

@Jude – no problem. No worries. I didn’t intend to imply that your question was the worst offender. I have been meaning to ask the question for some time. You just reminded me. Thanks!

El_Cadejo's avatar

There should just be a diff category for NSFW questions. That way the “NSFW” or anything that can possibly be in the title wont even cross your screen.

markyy's avatar

You’re absolutely right, titles should not contain NSFW words. It’s actually stated in the Fluther guidelines: ”Your questions still need to meet the guidelines for the section in which you post it in, and the question title must still be “safe for work”.”

As mentioned before, we do send back questions like that, you just caught us showing up late for work today :p The question was sent back to the user and I’m sure it’ll be back up with a more ‘suitable for work’ title asap. I hope that answers your question :)

jonsblond's avatar

There are also people using the computer at their local library (I’ve done this when we didn’t have internet at home) or users Fluthering from home with children in the house. I certainly don’t want some random kid at the library or my 7 year old looking over my shoulder and reading some of these titles.

ucme's avatar

It’s kind of like telling my teenage son not to look at the TV because there’s a gorgeous naked gal on there. Yeah right, he’s sure not to look ;¬}

markyy's avatar

@ucme NSFW tags aren’t meant to discourage users from clicking on a question, but rather to prevent from offending them, the people who are in range to see the user’s monitor, and internet filters that block sites based on a list of keywords. NSWF tags are common among the internet and are certainly not restricted to sexual content. Think of an NSFW tag like more of a warning/disclaimer.

ucme's avatar

Oh i’m aware of that, you misunderstood my intent. All i’m saying is that a question “guarded” with an nsfw tag, should have the “sensitive” aspect to it hidden within the details.
Probably a clumsy attempt at getting my point across I concede.

tom_g's avatar

Thanks everyone. Also, looks like the example I had used has been updated (”(NSFW) A question about male and female anatomy (details inside)”). Works for me.

blueberry_kid's avatar

I’m not sure either!

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther