@Mariah I think emotion needs to be considered in many situations. Which areas of logic does emotion need be present to make it logical, or fop logic to work?
@Coloma It’s not so much the emotion or the logic, it is how everyone is triggered. How would one get triggered if not by their emotion? Logic itself, is just situations and facts, and how to come up with the most likely, or reasonable outcome. It makes not decision that doing it makes one happy, mad, sad or whatever. There will be people that will read this and make it more than it is because they let emotion divert them from actually seeing the question stripped to the bone enough to answer it.
@laureth Emotion, I think, is useful or it wouldn’t still be with us. Of course, if we did not have emotions we would not have sympathy, empathy, compassion etc.
Emotion tells you what to do before logic has a chance to reason it out. In most things, it is the logic that tells you how to act before you fathom the emotions. You are in a room and a gas leak breaks out in a fireball. The logical thing is get away from the fire. You spring up and seek an escape, if there are other people there too you might try and save them, especially family. You fall over the side of a wall, logic tells you to try to get your feet under you. This happens before you even have time to be scared you are falling. Soldiers on patrol come under fire, logic tells you to go for cover. I have spoken to many soldier who have returned home, and they say the same thing, when a firefight breaks out you go to your training. Where not to go, where to watch for an ambush, how to cover your buddies, etc. They say they do not have time to be scared. Back to the dog. If a dog attack a lot goes into your fight or flight choice. You would not run from a dog that was 6lb and more bark than bite, unless your emotion overshot the logic that the dog is so small it probably couldn’t even get its mouth around your ankle, and a swift kick would likely punt the little pooch like a pigskin on the gridiron. Even then, your logic is telling you to fight or flight even if you have not thought out how you will run, or where to, or how you will fight.
@Simone_De_Beauvoir Sometimes, emotion is logic’s clarifier. Example please…….
@Vunessuh I don’t always consider utilizing emotion as harmful or counterproductive. I do not believe emotion should not be used or suppressed in all situations, in the right perspective it is very helpful.
What you think is logical may not be for someone else and what you consider emotional or a knee-jerk response may make perfect sense to everyone else. If 12 people stay in the water when a shark swims in the area, believing it is a logical not to get back in the boat, because they are not seals, is no guarantee they will not get bit. If I am in my car and about to exit, then someone comes out of nowhere and cuts in, I can lay on the horn and flip the other driver off. That could be seen as logical to many but there is more to it. The reason the other driver cut in could be more than just them acting like a douche bag, they might have not been familiar with the area, that was the exit they needed, and if they missed it, they would be lost. They were inattentive, the exit caught them off guard, and they thought they had more room. They simply didn’t see you. Thinking that they did it intentionally and flipping them off could logically escalate the situation needlessly.
You have nothing but an opinion regarding how other jellies operate. Whether you think they are emotional or logical usually aren’t facts and it can’t be measured by who does or doesn’t agree with your personal point of view. First part first, If any other Jelly post in the thread they are in, it is not my opinion, I see what they said and how they said it. If they were not answering the question, they weren’t. If you asked someone if they like banana and they go off on how they don’t eat bananas because so-in-so nation don’t give the banana puckers a decent shake, they didn’t answer the question asked, that is a fact, not any opinion of mind. The second part, again, it is not incumbent of my personal views. In fact I never said anything of the sort, where you got that from who can guess. If there is a thread about, veganism let say, and one Jelly says to another because he will not give up steak and the vegan Jelly says that he is an animal butcher, that came from emotion not logic. If the meat-eating Jelly never cut up a dead animal carcass, he can’t logically be a butcher. If the term butcher is used because his desire to eat meat keeps the beef industry going, it was a emotional response and not one from logic, has nothing to do with if I agree or not.