Cook’s Illustrated has an indoor pulled pork recipe. It is one of my favorite recipes ever, which is saying A LOT, and it’s not even very hard—way easier than messing with a grill. I’d also make their coleslaw recipe and put the slaw on the sandwich. Here’s both of them. I seriously cannot recommend these recipes enough, it’s friggin’ amazing. Just make sure you follow all the instructions exactly.
…
INDOOR PULLED PORK
Note: Sweet paprika may be substituted for smoked paprika. Covering the pork with parchment and then foil prevents the acidic mustard from eating holes in the foil. Serve the pork on hamburger rolls with pickle chips and thinly sliced onion. The shredded and sauced pork can be cooled, tightly covered, and refrigerated for up to 2 days. Reheat it gently before serving.
INGREDIENTS
• 1 cup plus 2 teaspoons table salt
• ½ cup plus 2 tablespoons sugar
• 3 tablespoons plus 2 teaspoons liquid smoke
• 1 boneless pork butt (about 5 pounds), cut in half horizontally (see step by step below)
• ¼ cup yellow mustard
• 2 tablespoons ground black pepper
• 2 tablespoons smoked paprika (see note)
• 1 teaspoon cayenne pepper
INSTRUCTIONS
1. Dissolve 1 cup salt, ½ cup sugar, and 3 tablespoons liquid smoke in 4 quarts cold water in large container. Submerge pork in brine, cover with plastic wrap, and refrigerate for 2 hours.
2. While pork brines, combine mustard and remaining 2 teaspoons liquid smoke in small bowl; set aside. Combine black pepper, paprika, remaining 2 tablespoons sugar, remaining 2 teaspoons salt, and cayenne in second small bowl; set aside. Adjust oven rack to lower-middle position and heat oven to 325 degrees.
3. Remove pork from brine and dry thoroughly with paper towels. Rub mustard mixture over entire surface of each piece of pork. Sprinkle entire surface of each piece with spice mixture. Place pork on wire rack set inside foil-lined rimmed baking sheet. Place piece of parchment paper over pork, then cover with sheet of aluminum foil, sealing edges to prevent moisture from escaping. Roast pork for 3 hours.
4. Remove pork from oven; remove and discard foil and parchment. Carefully pour off liquid in bottom of baking sheet into fat separator and reserve for sauce. Return pork to oven and cook, uncovered, until well browned, tender, and internal temperature registers 200 degrees on instant-read thermometer, about 1½ hours. Transfer pork to serving dish, tent loosely with foil, and let rest for 20 minutes.
5. Using 2 forks, shred pork into bite-sized pieces. Toss with 1 cup sauce (see below) and season with salt and pepper. Serve, passing remaining sauce separately.
…
LEXINGTON VINEGAR SAUCE
Note (from Qingu): I guess this is a western-style barbecue sauce because it has ketchup. For an even tangier, Eastern-North-Carolina style sauce, leave out the ½ cup water and replace the ketchup with ½ cup distilled white vinegar. I actually like the ketchup-less sauce better; so does my fiancée (but she might be biased because she hails from Eastern NC).
INGREDIENTS
• 1 cup cider vinegar
• ½ cup ketchup (or distilled white vinegar for Eastern-style)
• ½ cup water (leave out for Eastern-style)
• 1 tablespoon sugar (use a bit more for Eastern-style)
• ¾ teaspoon table salt
• ¾ teaspoon red pepper flakes
• ½ teaspoon ground black pepper
INSTRUCTIONS
Combine all ingredients in medium bowl with ½ cup defatted cooking liquid, reserved from step 5 of Indoor Pulled Pork with Sweet and Tangy Barbecue Sauce (see related recipe) and whisk to combine.
…
COLESLAW
Note: Do not use a pre-shredded coleslaw mix with this recipe; its texture and flavor are inferior to fresh cabbage. If you don’t have a salad spinner, use a colander to drain the cabbage, and press with a rubber spatula to remove all excess liquid. When it comes to the sweetness level of coleslaw, tastes vary. For this reason, prepare the coleslaw as directed and then season to taste with up to 2 teaspoons of sugar or up to 2 teaspoons of vinegar, adding one teaspoon at a time.
INGREDIENTS
• ¼ cup cider vinegar , plus extra for seasoning
• 2 tablespoons vegetable oil
• ¼ teaspoon celery seed
• ¼ teaspoon ground black pepper
• ½ large green cabbage (about 1 pound), cored and shredded fine (about 6 cups)
• ¼ cup sugar , plus extra for seasoning
• Table salt
• 1 large carrot , peeled and grated
• 2 tablespoons chopped fresh parsley leaves
INSTRUCTIONS
1. Combine ¼ cup vinegar, oil, celery seed, and pepper in medium glass or metal bowl. Place bowl in freezer until vinegar mixture is well chilled, at least 15 minutes and up to 30 minutes.
2. While mixture chills, toss cabbage with ¼ cup sugar and 1 teaspoon salt in large microwave-safe bowl. Cover with large plate and microwave on high power for 1 minute. Stir briefly, re-cover, and continue to microwave on high power until cabbage is partially wilted and has reduced in volume by ¬one-third, 30 to 60 seconds longer.
3. Transfer cabbage to salad spinner and spin cabbage until excess water is removed, 10 to 20 seconds. Remove bowl from freezer, add cabbage, carrot, and parsley to cold vinegar mixture, and toss to combine. If desired, adjust flavor with sugar or vinegar. Season with salt to taste. Refrigerate until chilled, about 15 minutes. Toss again before serving.