I would get all passionate and say what I think is happening and what I want to have happen. Then I’d see if the other person had any ideas or perspectives that I hadn’t thought of. If they don’t come up with anything, then it’s over. If they have something that can make you see it freshly, then maybe there’s a chance.
If you love this person, I would make it clear that you do love them. Sometimes, though, that isn’t enough. Sometimes there are external circumstances that get in the way and there is nothing you can do… or nothing you are willing to do that is enough to save the relationship.
It can be a great deal or torture when you are in this position. You love this person so much, but they aren’t really available. This is especially true in long distance relationships, I have found. Distance is a huge barrier. People have lives they have built. They are unwilling to upset the apple cart, even if it is true love. Even if it is a soulmate.
It’s amazing how much power the comfort of a situation one knows well is. To give that up for the other person so the relationship can take the next step—overwhelming. Especially if one person is more impatient than the other. In my experience, women take a longer time, and men tend to need things to happen more quickly.
In the end, I think you are right. No matter how much you fight, the structural difficulties of the situation make the relationship impossible. With all the will in the world and all the passion in the world and all the communication in the world, once things have gotten to a certain point, you can’t mend the tear. It’s over.
That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t still fight. You should fight on. There’s a chance you can fix it. And you may need to fight in order to get closure in your own mind. You need to do everything you can. Every little fucking thing you can, just in case some miracle happens, but it will be a miracle if it does happen. But then, perhaps I’m a fool because I believe in miracles, especially in matters of love.