That really depends on the place, and how welfare works there. Same for the jobs, and what the minimum wages are. That, and your living situation, if you have kids, roomates, where you live, like a house, or an appartement…
Here in Québec I spent about three months on welfare. You get about 600 dollars a month. I had to pay my rent with that, which is nearly 500 bucks. That doesn’t leave much for spending, and I got really late in my electricity bills during those months. Those months were horrible, and I had to sell some video games just so I could get some damn food.
In Winnipeg, you get less money per month, but they pay 200 dollars of your rent. I lived in a rooming house that cost 214 a month, and I got by, but I had to get the strict essentials, and nothing more. Eventually I found work, which wasn’t minimum wage, but just about. I fared much better then, but not by a big increase. Except I ate much better food and was able to buy fun things for myself every now and then. No bills to pay in a rooming house ecxept your rent though. But living in a rooming house is fuckin horrible.
So, it can depend on a lot of things. To make it simpler, calculate how much welfare a recipient gets in your area, then calculate the minimum wage and multiply it to four forty hour weeks, and compare. If I do that for my area, you get a lot more by working. (and here, welfare doesn’t pay part of your rent, although you do get more benefits if you have kids)
So again, you gotta weight out a lot of factors first, I guess, for a clear answer.
So, in that case, working shit pay was better than welfare for me.
I can tell you one thing about welfare to work transition though…welfare ain’t no fuckin vacation lol. In Winnipeg, they do everything they can to discourage you from collecting. Sometimes your cheques don’t arrive, and you gotta go down there and fight for em lol. They also offer lots of job finding programs you have to join, so that can always help, for those having trouble finding something. But yeah, the government doesn’t want you on there, at all haha.
In Québec, you could probably live your whole life on it. They don’t seem to give a shit. But what you get isn’t enough to cover daily life costs. Both my times on welfare, I was wanting a job, and I was wanting it fast lol.