@jerv I’m not saying that a Mac is the ideal machine for your needs. Simply that it’s common for people to spec out a “comparable” PC and a Mac and point to how huge the price difference is, but they end up ignoring a lot of the features resulting in an apples to oranges comparison (pun is regrettably unavoidable).
I completely agree that it’s possible to write decent software on other platforms, but I object that OS X is a walled garden. You can run any software you want, from your favorite flavor of Linux to Windows. Furthermore, you can install anything you want on OS X, and even when Mountain Lion is release, you will always have the option to run anything (although the default setting prevents code that isn’t signed by a developer who registered with Apple). Also, why is there such an absence of elegant, well designed, and beautiful software on these other platforms? What are some examples of truly sexy apps for Linux, Windows or something else?
As far as the PC != Windows, you’re of course absolutely correct. Although, if one asked 100 people on the street that question I think > 95% of them would wrongly think they were the same.
@amujinx “running a Mac without any anti-malware software is extremely foolish.”
The reality is that there are no serious threats in the wild for an up-to-date system that don’t involve tricking the user into manually authenticating malicious software (and there’s not much of anything that can protect even the most secure system from that kind of problem). To quote one Apple software engineer: “You couldn’t get me to install Norton on OS X if you slipped me the date rape drug.” (Source). I’ve personally met several Apple engineers and none that I spoke with would dream of running anti-malware. I know many OS X and iOS developers and they don’t run it either. These are not “extremely foolish” people, they’re taking a calculated risk say 1 in 100,000,000 chance that they’ll get an infection vs. running software that’s burning up tons of resources in the background and annoying the fuck out of them constantly with false positive alerts. Furthermore, Anti-Virus software has the potential to be much more vulnerable as an attack vector than the OS it’s supposed to be protecting.
As far as your comparison, I’d like to see the specs—I’ll bet you’re doing an apples to oranges comparison. If you get the ram for the MacBook Pro from Crucial (every Mac geek I know of does) I suspect that gap drops by a lot.
Addressing the “it’s all marketing hype” argument, read the 300+ page OS X Human Interface Guidelines and I think you’ll appreciate the depth of though involved in the design. In many ways reading the HIG is a great way to understand Steve Jobs, the way he thought, and the essence of what really sets Apple apart.