Can a woman be tested and get accurate Y Dna results?
Asked by
Dog (
25152)
March 7th, 2012
Under what circumstances would this be possible?
Observing members:
0
Composing members:
0
13 Answers
I assume you mean Y chromosome. The only way I think this is possible is if the woman in question is a post op transexual.
I don’t understand the question. Women are XX. No Y in there. Except for women who are genetically men, but identify as women.
I would think so. There are some people with a third set of sex linked chromosomes so why wouldn’t a woman be able to carry some part of a Y chromosome.
That is what I thought. Thanks guys.
By the way- it is in regards to the results of a DNA test which I am now certain was somehow confused with another sample.
@Dog That’s the most likely scenario, either that or contamination. There are guys that are XYY was what I was referring to.
Actually, I think that technically, they can. It is rare, and an abnormality but if interested look up Swyer Syndrome.
It sounds like an argument could be made that, technically, a person with this syndrome is not really female but a male with female characteristics depending on how or what you consider “makes” you male or female,.
XY XXY and XYY are all male. Y makes penises.
X XX… XXXXXX(I think that’s the largest set they ever found in a person) are female. No Y, no penis, not male.
Pretty sure you can be XY and not have a penis. Probably something goes wrong in utero and testosterone does not release as it should. Genetalia can be “mal formed” with any combination of DNA.
My bad, look up XY gonadal dysgenesis. Chromosomally male, physically appearing female, can’t experience puberty.
No. A woman (at least a woman who was born a woman) doesn’t have a Y chromosome.
If you have one or more “Y” chromosomes, then you are a biological male.
* A normal male has an “XY” chromosome pair.
* A male with Klinefelter’s Syndrome has “XXY.”
* A male with Supermale Syndrome has “XYY.”
If you have no “Y” chromosomes, then you are a biological female.
* A normal female has an “XX” chromosome pair.
* A female with Turner’s Syndrome has one “X.”
* There are females known as XY-females, but these are really biological males who had suffered an “unfortunate” injury while in the womb or during birth and were raised as females.
There may be other combinations that I am not aware of, but it is the presence of a “Y” chromosome that makes you biological male, and the absence of a “Y” chromosome that makes you biological female.
Of course, you can be biologically male and be anatomically female through surgery, and visa-verse. But you can’t change what you are genetically.
Answer this question
This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.