Are songs in waltz tempo more open to parody?
I was thinking back to parodied songs I remember from childhood, like On Top of Old Smokey and Battle Hymn of the Republic. It seems that most, if not all, of them have ¾ tempo. Is there something inherently funnier about 1–2–3, 1–2–3 than 1–2–3–4, 1–2–3–4? Is it easier to come up with lyrics?
Observing members:
0
Composing members:
0
7 Answers
Probably because it is “bouncier” than other tempos.
The time signature for The Battle Hymn of the Republic is 4/4. So you have disproved your own hypothesis.
I can’t imagine why there would be any relationship between time signature and openness to parody. So, absent theory and absent any evidence suggesting such a relationship, I’d say the answer to this question is an unqualified NO!
@marinelife ,Thanks for the correction. My music talent is definitely deficient. I still think it would be of interest to see if there are certain characteristics of music, apart from lyrics, that make them more likely to being parodied. And I am not giving up so fast on my waltz hypothesis, even if there are exceptions.
From off the top of my head, here are songs that I heard parodied as a youngster. I looked up the signatures.
Turkey in the Straw – 2/4
My Country Tis of Thee – ¾
Dance of the Hours (hello, muddah) – 2/4
Clementine – ¾
Stars and Stripes Forever – 4/4
Bridal Chorus (here comes the bride) 2/4
Twinkle Twinkle Little Star – 2/4
My survey turns up a predominance of 2/4, lending credence to @zenvelo ‘s suggestion.
There’s a “waltz” in 5/4 time in Tchaikovsky’s 5th Symphony.
Songs in ¾ time that come to mind as being often parodied in old cartoons are “Ach du Lieber Augustin; “Over the Waves” (played on a trombone when somebody is drunk or seasick); “Blue Danube” waltz by Strauss, which lends itself nicely to certain sound effects; etc. I think a lot of children’s songs are in ¾.
And don’t forget “Happy Birthday to You” which is also in ¾ time. Do those 2 old ladies still get royalties when it’s played in movies?
As a final comment, consider the trimeter structure of limericks.
Answer this question