Well, sometimes mods read stuff into questions and take action. Issues of interpretation are tricky. Issues of intention are tricky. What if I had no intention of suggesting something, yet that’s how the mod reads my question. I may be purely innocent, but I’m SOL, because the mod sees something there that they don’t like.
In normal life, we can argue a case like that, but online, moderators can banish your opinion from view, and there’s nothing to argue. In the real world, cops have the guns. You gotta do what they say, even when they are wrong. In the online world, the mods have the power to disappear you. You gotta do what they say, even when they are wrong.
I think it’s pretty sad, because they create a pretty harsh form of the character of a place in this way, and usually don’t know they are doing so. If it is pointed out, they deny they are forming anything. But they don’t see what else they can do. They have to make judgment calls. Then they live with them, as do the rest of us, unless we choose to leave.
I think that’s why a lot of people leave when modded. It may seem childish and unimportant, but at the heart, fluther is about free speech. In reality, we do not have free speech, but it is the illusion of free speech that is important. People get invested in that, and then, suddenly, they run up against a moderation that seems completely unfair and wrong, and what can they do? Sure, it’s not that important in the overall scheme of life, but most people want to believe they stand for something. Stand on principle. And the only way to stand on principle here, since we have no power at all, is to take ourselves away, and hope that someone cares enough to ask after us.
It’s quite manipulative, I guess, but on the other hand, when you have no power, that’s all that’s left. Your presence.
Or absence.