Everyone has a right to want what they want. That doesn’t mean they automatically get it. That’s a negotiation with the spouse. If a woman wants her husband to throw out his porn, he has a right to ask why. If she can’t give him any reasons, then it doesn’t make sense. She must have a reason. If she can’t articulate it, then they can’t talk about it, and they can’t solve any problem.
Why would she want him to throw it out? Does it threaten her in some way? How? Is it taking time from her? Is it causing him to lose his desire for her? Is he walking around with a boner all the time? Is he getting frisky with inappropriate people? What?
Further, even if there is a problem, how will throwing out the porn solve this problem? Will she also ask him to stop using the computer so that he doesn’t look at the internet. Or will she ask him to unhook the computer from the internet? Will she ask him to remove all porn from the computer? If so, how will she make sure he has complied? Or is magazine or book porn a problem, but internet porn is not? If so, why not?
Is the goal to stop him from seeing the stuff? Why? If so, then it doesn’t matter whether he throws it out because he has infinite access to porn on the internet. She has to trust him if he agrees not to look at porn, and trust does not require he throw anything out. Only that she believe he no longer looks.
Is her goal to get rid of material so she doesn’t have to see it? Then again, he need not throw it out. He only has to put it in a place she agrees not to look. Is her goal to make sure a child doesn’t see it? Then they only need to hide it instead of throwing it out.
I guess I don’t see how this is the man’s problem. There is nothing he can do to make his wife feel better, except to help her trust him. She is the one who is bothered by the porn, and no amount of throwing it out will get rid of it. Porn is ubiquitous and easy to get at.
If her issue is with his behavior towards her, then throwing out the porn won’t help. She needs to deal with his behavior. She needs to ask him for what she really wants—attention, presumably. The porn is not the issue. The lack of attention is. Or whatever it really is.
Porn is really a side issue and it isn’t related to the real issue in a way that getting rid of porn will affect the real issue. The real issue, most likely, is the relationship between the couple. That is what needs to be dealt with. Deal with that, and the porn will become irrelevant. If you only deal with porn, you won’t get at the real issue, and you will be just as unhappy as ever.