General Question

ETpro's avatar

What desktop-replacement laptop should I go for?

Asked by ETpro (34605points) October 12th, 2012

It’s time to retire the old tower I built up from parts. With a 5-year-old Intel Pentium processor and just 512 Megs of memory, it’s not even up to browsing today’s web. Throw a sophisticated formula at it and apply it to 10,000 rows of a complex Excel spreadsheet, and you can take a coffee break and come back to find it still thrashing.

I could just grab a new mother board, processor and some 1 gig memory modules and patch up the old tower system. I’ll do that sooner or later anyhow, as I have a new 1TB drive set for it and a spare Radeon HD 6850 graphics card with 1GB of GDDR5 memory on it.

But the old hard drive took a hit while moving this month, and won’t boot. Searching through my CDs, I no longer have the original Win-XP Complete CD. I have two upgrade CDs for XP, and so far have been unable to find my upgrade disk for Win 7 Enterprise Edition or any full edition to start upgrading a new drive from. So I am probably looking at buying an expensive complete edition of Win 7 Ultimate, going OEM, or switching it to Linux.

What’s more, today’s laptops are capable of far more than my old tower is. If I go with a desktop replacement laptop, I can plug in a keyboard, mouse and 24” monitor for work at home, and still have a laptop with a 1TB drive and all my current files on it when I have to travel. And it will come with the OS already installed at a fraction of what I would pay for a full copy (not an upgrade).

I do Web design and potentially video editing and graphics up to 3D design on it, but never really push a machine like gamers do. So I have no need of the fastest processor and many gigs of memory. Instead of paying for untapped horsepower, I’d rather keep the budget down around the $4 to $600 range and target something that has a good reputation for lasting.

What are some good quality, well supported desktop-replacement laptops to consider?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

18 Answers

Hawaii_Jake's avatar

I am not a computer whiz, but I trust the folks at CNET.com to give thorough reviews of all the latest gadgets and computers. Their ratings of laptops can be found here.

Bellatrix's avatar

I’m not a computer expert so I don’t know how helpful this will be. I have a Toshiba Qosmio that I am very happy with it. My only peeve is that it is now about 18 mths – 2 years old and I need to replace the battery. Other than that (touching wood) it’s great. I have had a couple of other Toshiba laptops and I prefer them to the IBM I had and there was another brand I had but I can’t remember the name.

I am not a gamer either but I multitask a lot and I use analytical software and usually have Word, Excel, Photoshop and other applications open at the same time.

My work laptop is a DELL and it’s also great. I can’t complain about it and the battery life is phenomenal. I was working for hours on it the other day and then realised it wasn’t plugged in. I have a docking station on my desk and a monitor so I get the best of both worlds. The flexibility of a laptop with the benefits of a big monitor at work. I don’t know how expensive a docking station set up is, but given your web design work, that might be something to consider. Also, I have heard (no idea if it’s true) that an area where the Apple brand really does excel is for those working in the graphics/design area.

I will be interested in hearing from other more expert computer people in the community.

mrlaconic's avatar

I like Lenovo’s I have been working with them 6+ years now professional and the number of service calls I put in for them in significantly less then I ever had with HP or Dell (for a 700 person company I submitted 1 service ticket a quarter for lenovo tops – for HP I was doing several a month for bad parts and dell.. well yeah nothing good to say about em).

Check out the Lenovo M series desktops they are great.

ETpro's avatar

@Hawaii_Jake Thanks for the link. Reading reviews is definitely part of my to-do list in sussing out which to target.

@Bellatrix At the moment I am working on a seven-year-old Toshiba. I’ve still got the original battery in it. It’s painfully slow now, though. I get lag even typing on Fluther. I’m a heavy-duty multitasker too, but this old laptop can’t handle more than a couple of applications open. Not enough RAM on board.

@mrlaconic Thanks for a professional report. I’ve heard that both Dell and HP have had quality issues of late. I’ll definitely have a look at the Lenevo M series.

Fred931's avatar

I do all of my computer shopping at Newegg.

Nvidia graphics, i5 processor, 4GBRAM, pretty rave reviews for this Lenovo.

ETpro's avatar

@Fred931 Thanks. Check this one out. Looks pretty good, and I am a Costco member.

mrlaconic's avatar

The thing you want to be careful with on Lenovo laptops that are NOT T series is that if you are not using an external mouse and keyboard make sure you have the ultra nav tools for the mouse enabled. The placement of the track pad is weird you will probably find that your hand slides over it while you type causing your curser to jump.

Otherwise that looks like a good deal to me.

ETpro's avatar

@mrlaconic It doesn’t mention anything about T series. How do I tell?

mrlaconic's avatar

The one you picked is a G series (Lenovo G6780)

mrlaconic's avatar

Sorry I meant G570 I clicked the link that @Fred931 posted by mistake. Either way the one you picked is a G. And to be fair I have never worked with G so I could be wrong but I have worked with the E, and T series and the biggest complaints I got (and experienced) about E was the touch pad issue. Never with the T

ETpro's avatar

I can’t see why, with an external keyboard and mouse, I’d ever get near the touch-pad. But it would be an issue when I run around with it outside the office. Thanks for the warning.

I have worked with touch-pads that suffered from poor human engineering. The only way I know of to protect yourself from that is to try one out on display in a store.

Response moderated (Spam)
the100thmonkey's avatar

Is Newegg the cheapest there is?

I just bought a desktop replacement laptop for my wife – 8GB DDR3, 500GB HDD, BR/DVD, Nvidia GTX555-M, Core i7 32** CPU, 1920×1080 display, etc. from a store here (in Japan) for 54,000 yen – $688.

Surely there’s a better $$$$:performance ratio out there.

ETpro's avatar

@the100thmonkey That’s a lot of computing power for the price. That show hold me for the foreseeable future. I don’t think Newegg is the price leader, but they do provide solid service whereas some of the fly-by-night sites do not.

Fred931's avatar

@the100thmonkey I have a good feeling your geography is the big reason for the price difference. How long and hard did you have to look to find something that cheap?

the100thmonkey's avatar

@Fred931: About 20 minutes.

Response moderated (Spam)
ETpro's avatar

@olko Maybe for this one’s replacement.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther