I know this is an old question but I was browsing through past days and saw it and thought I should try to spread a bit of love here… sorry it wound up being so long. I’m feeling verbose tonight, I guess.
I plan to upgrade. I love the metro interface on my phone—it’s quite intuitive. Mostly, I want the improved pen input—windows 8 pro has digitizer input functionality. A tiny nib, an eraser on the other end, and OneNote with improved inking waiting for me. I really want to be be able to take notes electronically in class. I’ve used a couple windows 8 tablets with the pen input, it’s quite nice, actually feels like a really smooth pen. Bring on the tablet!!
If my current laptop weren’t in the process of dying, I might hold off. I agree that it’s not necessary to switch from 7 to 8 if your hardware remains the same, but not because 8 is ineffective or ineffecient; just because the much of the 8 interface isn’t that different, 7 still works well, and I tend to delay purchases in general.
I had the beta version of 8 on my computer for a while, and actually, it ran smoother and faster. Also, once I learned the hotkeys, I moved around 8’s OS faster: my fingers rarely needed to leave the keyboard to use the mousepad. I wound up reinstalling my old version of Windows for two reasons—first was that iCloud refused to load (I do have an iPad). That being my only way to move files off the iPad, I needed it. iCloud’s site was literally the only one, I have no idea what its stinginess was about; second, I would have to reinstall 7 anyway, because the beta would expire, and you wouldn’t get the upgrade-deal with the beta if you wanted it.
The major differences:
– You have the metro start screen instead of a start button. Some people whine about this, I’m not sure why, it’s really not a difficult concept. Getting the 8’s pro version, you have a desktop mode for legacy applications, so it really does just feel like a menu. Some people think this is “jarring”, whatever. I’m glad they’ve left a space for old software to still work as the environment changes.
– The metro apps fill the screen like perpetually having pressed F11. This concerned my open-ten-windows self, until I realized I only actually look at one or two windows at a time anyway despite the comforting stack behind. The way you navigate between the full-screen apps helps with this immensely. Quick flicking/buttons flips you between apps, shows a scrolling list of all open, closes apps, snaps two on the screen, etc.
– You have swipes/corners/hotkeys to reveal actions that used to be found only by moving your mouse around the screen. This is probably the biggest change, that many of the buttons and actions are now slightly tucked away. It keeps the screen tidier and the interaction smoother so long as you remember that all the actions still are there, just not all staring you down at once.
As for the feared loss of productivity, I understand this. Brings me back to my iPad, actually: it was a grad gift to use for school, and it’s now mostly just an expensive but lightweight collection of textbooks, with too many notetaking apps. Other than save my back quite a lot of weight, it doesn’t do anything very functional. And so it’s this weird device that I don’t otherwise need, it’s just a lot of media and consumption, a strange new definition of the term ‘tablet’. Whether or not you personally like their implementation, Microsoft’s concept behind windows 8 was that tablet can be function, that it should be function. I know someone who works for Microsoft. The company has already (quietly) given all their employees new windows 8 machines to work from, so they clearly believe they’ve produced a productive interface. I asked the person, if he was able to work from the new software. He said he took a day to learn the new parts of the UI, and that was that. He still does everything he used to, and says that he’s faster than he had been, which is saying something. Plus, many of the additions are fun and useful. The picture password, for example.
But then, I’m one of those few people in the world to have a zune. I love the thing. Its build quality is the reason I’m waiting for the Surface Pro release.