Dollars are a metaphor for value. They reflect the value of everything that people value, except in reality, they just reflect the value of goods and services.
Dollars don’t get borrowed into existence. They don’t get printed into existence. They already exist as long as people value things or stuff that people do.
What we need is a way of agreeing that the amount of dollars we (collectively) print is equal to all the goods and services we produce or have. So, to some degree, that is an arbitrary amount, at first. We have all this stuff. Let the public bank print 100 dollars and that will be worth all the goods and services we have in the US. Ok. Let’s call it 100 billion dollars.
Now, we put all this money in circulation. Now we have a way for people to trade the stuff they have and the stuff they do with other people without having to barter, which is very illiquid and slow.
It all works fine as long as we all agree that the amount of dollars in the system equals the amount of goods and services. But if people cheat, mistrust enters, and we’re in trouble.
So lets say the banks encourage people to borrow more than a house is worth. They are pumping more money into the system but not increasing the value of goods and services. People go to sell their house, and no one will buy at that price. Suddenly, there is too much money for the amount of stuff, and money has to deflate in value. Bad for the economy. People stop buying things, and companies lay people off, and we have recession.
I may not have gotten the direction of the inflation or deflation correct here, but the idea that money and stuff are out of balance is what causes the lack of trust in the system and what causes the problems we have.
Anyway, people are out of work. Factories are idle. There is still a lot of stuff and capacity, but no one believes it is balances, and so without confidence, the economy slows. We need to rebuild trust. We need to regulate the banks so they can’t play games with the money. They can’t give loans where houses aren’t worth the money being loaned.
Once people are confident that dollars equals stuff, they will invest and work and build again. We’ll make more stuff and do more work, and we’ll need more dollars in the system to stand for all that stuff.
Dollars are nothing. Even if we had the gold standard, gold would be nothing. Money, whether you use shells or diamonds, is only worth something when people believe it is an accurate reflection of all the stuff in the economy. There is a one to one relationship between money and stuff. All the stuff equals all the money, no matter how much money there is or what we use for money. Money is just a technology; an agreement; that allows us to trade more efficiently. Money, on it’s own, is nothing. Worthless.
So first dollar borrowing is not really a relevant scenario.
We lend money because we believe people will make enough stuff to be worth that money. It is a conceit, if you will, that allows us to give people a way to trade for things they haven’t yet made, but plan to make. It is a gesture of trust. Once people make stuff, they can sell it. The value is there, and they keep some for their own account, and use some to pay back those who trusted them in the first place.
Banks are traditionally the ones who establish the credibility and credit-worthiness of people who state an interest in creating stuff. We trust banks, traditionally, because they are known to be sober and careful. But if we don’t watch them, they will start taking wild stupid risks, and then they aren’t the right group to entrust the process of equating money and stuff in the world to.
People usually make the mistake of thinking that money is something real. It isn’t. It is a metaphor. But if you can’t get past this idea that money is purely an idea, you’ll want gold or something to make you feel secure. It won’t work, because it is a misunderstanding of what money is, but for a moment, you might feel secure, because you can hold onto gold.
Money is nothing. It is an idea. What is real is what we make and what we do. Money is a fiction we create to enable us to trade the products of our labor. Money only works if we believe there is an accurate relationship between it and stuff. Banks manage that relationship. They do the lending. They make sure people pay back. As long as we keep the banks under control, we can maintain trust and stability, and your dollars can be loaned out and repaid.