My honor is very important to me, as I think it is to everyone. But I’m not one for honor killings. I don’t think my wife’s reputation determines mine. Nor do my kids’ reputations. I don’t think honor is something to kill over. Rather, I think honor is about reputation. It’s about having people take your word as your true word. It’s about consistently standing for your values. It’s about recognizing when you are wrong and changing. It’s not about staying the same just because you think that’s what honor is.
I think that many people all over the world use symbols in the place of honor. So they’ll kill a daughter that has sex out of wedlock. Or they’ll kill an opponent who insulted them or dissed them in some way. This is a primitive notion of honor, and it is usually held by thugs and very rich people and poorer people, especially in very fundamentalist cultures.
To my mind, that’s just a caricature of honor. It’s ignorant honor. Real honor is intelligent and educated and nuanced. It changes with circumstances. It is based on what is right in this situation, not on some one size fits all principle that ends with men killing women because they think they own the women.
I’m 56 and I live in Philly. I’m male. I would say that there is a broad range of notions of honor where I live. We have mafiosi with one notion. We have academics with another. We have business people and artists and immigrants and everyone has a different idea, although I’m sure that most of the ideas overlap quite a bit, too.
Honor, I think, is a person’s sense of integrity. Some people will do anything to make a buck. Others will only do things they think will help all of society. Many have a personal sense of honor that is based on their own values, derived from first principles. These people are easier to trust and work with because you can understand where they are coming from.
Other people follow someone else’s set of rules without realizing they are making their own interpretation, which means it is their own rules. These are people who think they have honor, but it is a convoluted honor because it is based on something outside of them that they internalize by imagining what their God wants them to do, not recognizing that their God is their own invention. These people have a kind of honor, but it is very convoluted and unpredictable.
But everyone has a sense of honor, and it is pretty easy to tell where they are coming from by how they choose to spend their lives. For some, money is most important. For others, relationships. Each has a different sense of honor.