Hi nayeight (and everyone). I thought about this question for a while, and hopefully can provide some insight as both a fellow Flutherer and a Moderator. Hopefully my verbosity doesn’t put you to sleep (not my intention).
While I don’t believe your original question was ill-willed or otherwise intended to be divisive, I would like to stress that “high quality” questions are those that are well thought out, and tend to address the community at-large, that is, questions that embrace the “spirit” of the collective-ness that we share here.
I want to give my compliments to the posters above, who have done a nice job of suggesting ways to strengthen the wording of your question and topic, which in this case, is a great example of what makes the collective special-that everyone brings their unique perspective and shares with the collective group. I think that your details in this particular question are far more interesting and thought provoking, as you gave detailed background as to the impetus for your question, as well as your reasoning for seeking the answer.
Your question, in its original form, while not overtly inappropriate, was worded rather narrowly (“How many black people are there on fluther? Description: Just wondering how many blacks are on hereā¦ Tags: black people”). Frankly, the manner and format of the question falls into the category of a poll question which, in general, are held in low regard in terms of quality (in any case or topic).
Whereas as a question that encourages all of the collective to participate and provide diverse insights follows the spirit of the collective-that we are inclusive (versus exclusive) in sharing insights and information, and furthermore, are given an equal opportunity to contribute and participate.
Again, this question you posed here in this discussion is IMO a stronger (higher quality) question than the original for that exact reason.
Also, nayeight, remember, that moderators are human, and try their best to make sound judgment calls; sometimes communications in either direction can be misinterpreted, but that’s why the option is always there for you (or anyone) to contact moderators via email reply or by the Contact link to clarify and discuss the matter in private. Moderators are usually very receptive to communication and are trained to help Flutherers (per request) to bring the question back to the collective. That’s why when a question is moderated (or pulled), the asker is given the opportunity to re-word or clarify the question and re-submit it for review.
I hope that this information helps and not hinders your participation in the collective-Fluther always encourages thought-provoking questions for all to read, learn from, and enjoy.
As always, feel free to contact us if you have any questions or would like to find out more information. You can also leave us a message in the chat room-Man O’ War and we’ll reply in short order. Thanks for being a part of the collective!