O.K. Thank you all, so much, for your answers.
I was kind of afraid to ask this question. It’s been a long time, 8 years or so maybe, since I had to do this, since my Bugsy, my cat, who was quite an avid hunter in his youth. He died at 18, 7 years ago and he had gotten old, old enough, couple of years before that to have lost his taste for hunting, and my Casper, who was never much of hunter to begin with, most of the time he settled for Bugsy’s slopppy seconds, died about 4 years ago… so it’s been long time…
As I mentioned, I thought I was done with this heartbreak but last night, when I had to kill the mouse, I started to question my normal method, which is to put the little creature in a plastic bag, I use Baggie brand bags, because I always have them around the house. I have Ziplocs too, but in terms of food storage, there are circumstances where I much prefer Baggies to Ziplocs… so anyway…
My standard procedure is to put the poor, sweet little creature in a Baggie and try to get as much air out of it as I can without causing the animal further pain and discomfort, and then tie it off, either by tying a knot in the Baggie or using a twist tie.
Is that horrible? To do that? CO kills by displacing the oxogyn in the brain with CO. In the time it would take me to generate CO, though if it is available in a can… I will have to look into that… the poor little thing could be dead. I know I have to kill the little creature, even if I don’t like it and don’t want to do it, but I don’t want to add to it’s suffering.
So is killing the animal by suffocating it the wrong way to go? That’s how I have always done it.
I would break it’s neck, clean and fast, as @rosehips suggested if it weren’t for the fact that I am so ham fisted, and more likely, simply not made of the stuff that would allow me to simply snap the little creature’s neck, even if it were the best and most humane way to deal with it.