Here’s an example of common sense and the law gone awry.
The school superintendent and all of the administrators between him and the teacher will swear up and down that they followed the law, and they very likely did – technically.
However, this reminds me of something that I saw last week on a construction jobsite. The contractor has a Safety Manual (which I was in Malaysia to audit). In the manual they have a “Fire Rescue Process Flow Chart”. I actually laughed out loud when I first read it. Here are the process boxes:
“Occurrence of fire”. Okay, sure. Fire occurs to start this process.
“Discovered”. No problems yet.
“Notify Contractor’s Safety Officer”. Here’s where they start to go off the rails.
“Notify Safety Manager”. Definitely off the rails.
In a side branch (parallel, but obviously secondary): “Notify Fire Brigade (if necessary)”
Under the “Safety Manager” box is “Conduct Site and Contractors Fire Fighting Organization”.
Do you see the problem? It’s pretty obvious if you look at this paper chart. There’s too much goddamn bureaucracy! Too many decision points. Too many people to “notify” before anything is actually done. This was why I joked with the contractor’s Safety Manager that by the time he makes a decision whether or not to call the site fire brigade, half of Malaysia could be in flames. (It’s a small country, after all.)
Here’s how you fight a fire: Notice fire. If it’s small enough to hit with a broom or a nearby fire extinguisher and put out, then do that. Otherwise “Sound the Alarm”.
Two steps.
The law needs to be changed so that the teacher is required to call the police and notify school administrators in a parallel and secondary path.
PS: This is actually a pretty good contractor.