No, I don’t really think so. I think the tone of the site is the responsibility of the owners. They are the ones who implement the policies that make it what it is. I think the success and failure rests mostly on the owners.
However, I do think it rests on us to some extent. I know I try to encourage the kind of discussion I like to see. I am not in favor of officiousness, but I do like serious and humorous discussion. I’m not fussy about language and grammar. I think we are capable of understanding more than many of us like to pretend.
Having said that, I do like precision. I like people to make it as clear as they can what they are referring to, instead of using imprecise pronouns where it is unclear which he, she, or it they are referring to. Name names, I say.
I also like people to use a certain style of interaction and play. So when people are smart and respectful, I think they should get the benefit of the doubt even when they say things most people don’t approve of. But when they say stupid things, I think they are fair game for derision.
A lot of people don’t agree with me there. They think people who say stupid things should be given respect, too. Ah well. I know what they mean, to some degree. But I guess it makes a difference what you think is stupid.
Anyway, there are a lot of smart people around, and they do seem to stick around. It’s harder to break in when you are new and you don’t know the past history.
I would love to see a blog of strategies for handling various problems that people typically encounter here. Like what do I do if I believe in god and I want to say that without getting clobbered. Or what do I do if I don’t know how to spell very well? Or what’s the deal with lurve? What’s the deal with the mods? Who can read pms? Why is lurve so hard to get? What’s with the prizes? How do I write a good question? Etc etc. Love to see an assemblage of collected fluther lore and history and how to be a good jelly advice.