Social Question

PhiNotPi's avatar

Do you mind answering this color survey, which may have deep implications into the nature of consciousness?

Asked by PhiNotPi (12686points) February 27th, 2013

The main question under investigation is “Do different people see colors differently?”

If two people look at an apple, they may be able to agree that the apple is “red.” Those two people, however, might actually see two different colors. Since both were taught to call those respective colors “red,” they would not notice the difference in normal conversation. They can describe the color in words, but they can’t jump inside each other’s consciousness to experience the other person’s vision.

I am trying to devise a survey to detect this. While looking at a color wheel, I noticed that although the color is constantly changing, it doesn’t always change at the same rate.

I want you to look at this color wheel. It is divided into sixteen equal segments. Pick three of those segments that have the most contrast from one end of the segment to the other. Post in your answer the letters assigned to those segments, in order from greatest to least contrast.

My reasoning behind this is that if another person sees different colors, the exact locations of high/low contrast may be different. There is no guarantee that this experiment will work, but if everyone’s answer is different, it will offer good evidence.

This survey was designed for people with full color vision, if you are in any way colorblind, please say so in your answer.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

58 Answers

rojo's avatar

A, C, H

ucme's avatar

This reminds me of Sesame Street, how fun!

rebbel's avatar

D, L, A

tedibear's avatar

A B and C

glacial's avatar

A, H, K

From looking at some of the answers, I’m not sure that everyone understood the instructions.

Jeruba's avatar

You know that colors vary in appearance from monitor to monitor, though, right?

B, H, A.

I agree with you, @glacial: it looks like some people are answering which three contrast the most with one another, rather than which segments show the most within-segment difference from one end to the other.

PhiNotPi's avatar

@Jeruba @Adirondackwannabe Arg, you might be right about misreading the directions. But, I can’t throw away any of the answers, because variation between responses is what we are trying to detect. Also, the between-monitor difference, which I knew a little bit about, might be too large compared to the natural differences we are trying to detect.

—————-

But, to try and make this thread worth something, here is a neat article that says that we don’t all see the same colors, and here is an informative Youtube video on the subject.

Adirondackwannabe's avatar

@PhiNotPi I read it quick the first time and thought it was which segments contrast with each other. It’s hard to pick out the segments that have the most contrast within them. I think it may depend on our preferences too. I like hot colors so my eye was drawn there first.

glacial's avatar

@PhiNotPi Also… I tend to think this is partly a trick question. My mind can’t let go of the assumption that that there is no way for me to compare the amount of contrast between completely different colours, so I reported them in a random order.

kitszu's avatar

A, E, H.

That said, we arn’t talking ‘colors’, we are talking about shades of color.

The way they fade into and absorb each other, eventually becoming a separate color.

hearkat's avatar

(oooops! I just re-read the instructions – I did it wrong.)

B A H

Adagio's avatar

B H L I definitely understood the question, from my perspective these three segments/spectrums have the most contrast from one end of the spectrum to the other.

zensky's avatar

Colour-blind. A, B, E.

ETpro's avatar

Before looking at anyone else’s answer, A, B, L. Now let’s see how I compare with other answers.

blueiiznh's avatar

Like omg @ETpro, we match. Call me in the morning and let me know what you are wearing~

wundayatta's avatar

A, B, H.

I notice that A and B show up a lot.

But I didn’t count the frequency of all the answers.

I suspect that there could be many other reasons other than people seeing colors differently to explain this variance.

Kardamom's avatar

Not checking anyone else’s answers until after I post. My answers are B H and A

ETpro's avatar

@blueiiznh Ha! Trust that my outfit will be color coordinated—at least to your well-calibrated eyes.

Sunny2's avatar

I misunderstood the question. Damn. My brain just doesn’t work as well as it once did.
Looking again and without looking at others’ answers: ABH

susanc's avatar

A, B, L.

susanc's avatar

Yeah, I used to teach color theory, I’m a painter, I can see these distinctions easily. But mostly, I think a lifetime of thinking about color made it easier for me to understand the instructions. Fun!

ucme's avatar

Upon further investigation… FBI, or possibly CIA.

dabbler's avatar

@PhiNotPi
Will you be surveying other folks? Will answers be correlated to some other sort of spectrum like Myers-Briggs ? We all want to know how crazy we really are!
Conclusions, please!

LuckyGuy's avatar

How about also recording the sectors with the least change? Some had virtually no change from one side to the other. To avoid confusion, I won’t write them here.

marinelife's avatar

I see colors the same as a bunch of you all!

rojo's avatar

Looked on a different monitor (an old Dell CRT). It did not change my answers.

flutherother's avatar

B A H that was without looking at anyone else’s answer.

susanc's avatar

Yay yay Augie!

augustlan's avatar

@PhiNotPi You’re going to have to make us a chart to show us how many answered with the same group of segments!

Kardamom's avatar

Does anyone see dead people?

flutherother's avatar

Just to be clear, B A H was my answer not a comment on the question. I just realised it could be interpreted that way.

Brian1946's avatar

B, H, A: the same answer as @Jeruba and @Kardamom.

SavoirFaire's avatar

@PhiNotPi I am curious how you see this survey as having deep implications for the nature of consciousness. We already know perfectly well that different people may see colors in different ways. The metaphysical and epistemological questions raised by thought experiments involving things like inverted qualia, however, typically have to do with the possibility of undetectable variations that cannot be explained via physical differences. Yet surely this survey is a means of detecting differences.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther