General Question

Ltryptophan's avatar

What did pirates look like?

Asked by Ltryptophan (12091points) March 14th, 2013

We have hollywood ideas of pirates, but what would the historical pirate look like?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

12 Answers

Response moderated (Unhelpful)
Berserker's avatar

Well the idea of grubby looking pirates isn’t far off. They spent a long time at sea without adequate resources, and had to make do with their clothing, which got worn out. Some of them probably shaved and cut their hair, but I’m guessing that at some point, some probably didn’t care anymore, at least not the ship hands. Different story for the members higher in the hierarchy, I believe.
Being a pirate meant you had the law on your ass all the time, and contrary to popular belief, treasure and such was not the highest on their list. When they could, food and medical supplies were their priority. Now that’s not to say they didn’t steal valuables and all; I mean that’s what they were in it for. Pirates did a lot of illegal trading and other types of contraband, but it wasn’t easy for them to spend what they got without someone alerting the authorities. prolly in the hopes of a reward from the high council haha That doesn’t mean they always dressed like slobs though; the most important figures of a pirate crew tried to dress in a way that showed class, as to further convince trade and social authority.
When they sacked some ship, clothing were also on their list. They took what they could get, and even if they looked like clowns with feathery hats and fluffy vampire blouses that they looted from some official government ship, they maintained those as best they could, since they knew they might have to keep them for a long while.

But actually, I’m just kind of guessing here. Obviously, hats and handkerchiefs were a must on a ship, to protect them from the intense day heat they so often encountered. You know, like baseball players.

Wooden legs and hook hands, I highly doubt that…to suffer such injuries like amputation without medical assistance most likely guaranteed death, or severe disability, especially back then.

And while pirates did capture exotic animals like parrots or monkeys, this was usually to sell the animals, and not keep them as pets. My guess is they looked like bikers, only without coats including so many unnecessary zippers.

pleiades's avatar

According to Disney, when they were being chased down by the Navy of some sort of nation they would switch their clothes up to “ordinary fishermen” whatever that means.

ETpro's avatar

Here’s info and what drawings or images there are for the 10 most infamous pirates.

Ltryptophan's avatar

@ETpro they look sharp…lol

Sunny2's avatar

@ETpro Thank you for the research. Very interesting.

Espiritus_Corvus's avatar

There is a lot of contemporary documentation on pirates, written by their victims and, in the case of the memoirs of A. O. Esquemelin, the pirates themselves, found on Project Gutenburg and the Internet Archive. Including contemporary woodcuts.

My knowledge pertains mainly to the Caribbean pirates on what was called the Spanish Main. As far as pirate dress, many Captains and officers adorned themselves in contemporary “gentlemen’s” clothes, or a hodgepodge of naval uniforms of their period—usually booty from victim ships of various nations, both civilian and military. These ships were English, American, Dutch, Spanish, Portuguese, and French, mostly, as were the fashions and uniforms found in them. Consider that many of these men didn’t change their clothes very often, and the clothes were silks, flannels, cottons and heavy wools. Heavy woolen Great Coats with filigree on the breast and buttonholes were in high demand as they denoted rank and served as protective clothing during raids. Pirates often operated in tropical and subtropical climates. Ships officers, many former navy men, insisted on wearing full dress, including great coats during raids and when around women in pirate-controlled ports like Port Royale, Grand Turk, and Trinidad.

The crew dressed much like the common men and sailors in contemporary cities such as Lisbon, Portsmouth, colonial Boston, or Toulon. Cotton pantaloons, collarless cotton blouses with broad sleeves, broad brimmed hats and scarves/handkerchiefs (as headbands to soak up sweat and around the waist as was the fashion) for protection from the sun, broad leather heavy buckled belts at the waist and across the chest for swords, some were barefoot, some wore the heavily buckled leather shoes of the period, some wore heavy knee-high boots. Again, this was protective clothing. Personal hygiene and daily dental care was nearly non-existent except among certain former privateers, gentlemen, who chose to extend their letters of marque beyond their intended use and become out and out pirates.

Considering the climates they operated in, the effect of weather and sun over period of years, the lack of hygiene, their affinity for strong spirits, poor diet, the infrequent change of clothing, frequent hand to hand combat, the crews stunk to high heaven, were missing teeth, were badly barbered, were quite shabby in their dress, looked much older than their years, and rarely lived beyond 30. But it is said they kept their vessels in immaculate condition, including regular careening and flushing the bilges. Care for weaponry was paramount.

Edward Teach, aka Blackbeard, was said to have jet black, greasy locks below his shoulders and an equally black and greasy long beard which he liked to braid and then light the ends on fire during raids for effect.

Anne Bonney was said to be fond of dresses, but found them impractical in her work, so she and her female companion dressed like common men of the period and often were mistaken for them.

Henry Morgan, owner of vast plantations and former Governor of Jamaica was a gentleman pirate of great success. According to contemporaries, he demanded near-naval discipline aboard his ships, although, like most pirates, he had his men sign the usual standard articles before coming aboard. This was a contract denoting rank and share dependent on skills and experience. Compensation for digits, eyes, and limbs lost during combat were commonly described in these articles. A list of men with appropriate skills for positions such as captain, navigator, first and second mates, was made and from this list the officers were elected. This was common practice among most pirate ships. Ships surgeon was a prized man and there was always a position open for one at near captain’s share. A. O. Esquimelin was a Morgan’s ship’s surgeon and later wrote about it and it is on the net. Morgan saw no reason to change his lifestyle or dress any more than he had to while he was a pirate captain. He was quite flamboyant.

Francoise L’Olonnaise was among the cruelest pirates in history. His punishments were extremely imaginative and sadistic, his murders frequent and arbitrary, his boardings and pillaging were merciless and among the most bloody. He favored black clothing with red shirts and scarves. He and Morgan combined forces on one raid and Morgan was so disgusted he avoid L’Olonnaise’ areas of operation thereafter. Morgan refused to take former L’Olonnaise crew onto his own. But I digress.

These men, for the most part, were badly barbered, dressed in period rags, had bad skin and teeth, were undernourisned, were often drunk and showed signs of frequent beatings and knife fights, and they smelled bad. Some were missing limbs and eyes. I imagine, like most drunks, these guys were pretty ornery. Not the kind of guy you’d want to take home to mother.

I think you would find Project Gutenburg and Internet Archive helpful.

Ltryptophan's avatar

@Espiritus_Corvus a nod to your fingers, and the risk of that typing being lost at any point, something which has happened to me.

Then I take it pirates as we know them, are not far off from fact. Interesting. I mean, in case I see one in my travels, I’d like to know who I’m dealing with.

Espiritus_Corvus's avatar

@Ltryptophan Thanks. I learned early here that when I found myself in an interminable protraction like the one above I’ll actually go to the trouble to transfer it to a word doc and continue there before copying it to the answer box. I never really expect people to read the long ones, but they’re fun to write and see on Fluther. Don’t you hate it, though, when you’re really into it, starting the umpteenth paragraph and BANG—someone uploads an answer and all your shit is gone? Keereist, that drives me crazy. And I really wish we had more edit time. All that bad grammar, dropped articles, improperly placed prepositional phrases, and missing qualifiers will be on the net forever. Kinda pedantic, huh? Pathetic.

Response moderated (Spam)
Cheekyface's avatar

What do you mean by ‘did’? They’re still out there, and there are way more now than there ever were. Just don’t go sailing around the coast of Asia, particularly in the high traffic shipping lanes of South East Asia and around the sub-continent, or Africa, especially Somalia. There, you will get an up front and very personal view of many of the modern pirates. The USA has many large ships both military and merchant, patrolling there.

tbrendan's avatar

You haven’t seen the movie Pirates of Caribbean? They actually look like Mr. Barbosa !

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther