Social Question

Drush545's avatar

People of non-American nationalities. What is your view of American accents?

Asked by Drush545 (229points) June 27th, 2013

I was born and raised in the American south east and I do have a rather subtle southern accent. It is light and fairly drawn out as well. I have gone other places within my own country and people usually like to hear me talk. I do not sound hickish either or uneducated in the slightest. I mean no offense in what I am about to say but, I have never cared much for the Northeastern Bronx or New York accent. Nor do I care for a particularly strong southern draw. Mid-western accents sound rather plain to me as well, as if they have no real accent. I have been around the country and there are so many accents here in America that it is hard to understand each other if you are from different parts of the country. So, I ask you, what is your opinion on American accents?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

26 Answers

JLeslie's avatar

I am married to someone who was born and raised in another country and he thinks very extreme southern accents make people sound not too bright. It’s probably more of a country southern accent. Some southern accents he appreciates and he likes the various sayings that are very southern, but some rub him the wrong way like when people say fixin’ to, and might could. The middle of the road accents I don’t think he has much of an opinion on. Basically any accent from any part of the country that sounds uneducated he notices. From yous guys in Jersey to saying ax instead of ask in the south to saying eye-talian in the midwest. Funny, he catches sometimes when people make grammatical errors or extreme pronounciation errors and just cannot believe an American born and educated here can make some of the mistakes. It is not only the accent, but also the speed at which someone talks. If it takes a person forever to get a sentence out, it doesn’t sound too swift. He loves British, Irish and similar accents. To him they sound much better than an American accent.

ragingloli's avatar

It sounds low class, and as if the speaker does not care about speaking properly.

bea2345's avatar

Many years ago, in Brooklyn, I heard a waitress yelling, “An Adam and Eve on a slab!” Her voice and accent had to heard to be believed, the diner was crowded, noisy, but the short order cook heard her. It (the order) is a kind of sandwich, I learned later. And later, in Chicago, I had difficulty understanding the bus conductor; he sounded strangled.

gailcalled's avatar

I have never heard of a region referred to either as the American southeast or the northeastern Bronx.

Do you mean a strong southern drawl rather than draw ?

And saying that “I mean no offense but..” means that you do mean to be offensive.

I was born in the Bronx and raised within 25 miles of Manhattan, traveled through much of the country and rarely have ever had trouble understanding most of my fellow Americans. Most of them have been able to understand me also.

linguaphile's avatar

Uhmm… Southern accents are the closest thing we have left to what the “King’s English” sounded like.

JLeslie's avatar

@gailcalled You probably have not been to that same poor part of Alabama I was in where I talked to a woman who I could only understand about every fifth word. My husband could not understand one. Same with that other woman from Mississippi. It’s rare, but there are some parts of the US the people have incredibly difficult accents to understand. Again, it is rare. It has only happened to me in the south, and I don’t think it is because I am from the northeast. I am very good at understanding people with accents. I don’t give up easily like some people do. I also have lived many places east of the Mississippi, so I am accustomed to many different accents.

I don’t think the OP was saying northeastern Bronx. He was saying accents in the northeast and gave examples of New York and the Bronx. I make fun of my mom’s Bronx accent. I like it. It’s not severe, but she does tend to add R’s to words that end in A, and A’s to replace ER at the end of a word. The NYC accent, like everywhere else, varies even within an individual burrough. That more extreme NewYoRican accent isn’t the same as your accent ever was I would bet. Actress Rosie Perez would be a very extreme example of it.

In MI some people were confused when I would say I would meet someone at quarter of 12. They don’t use of in that context.

In TN some people refer to downstairs as the main floor, even if you are on the main floor and there is a basement. The first time it happened to me was in a museum. The woman at the entrance explained to us what exhibits were downstairs and what was upstairs. We thought there was a downstairs from the main level, she said the miscommunication happens often with people from put of state.

Some parts of the country say next Tuesday to mean a week from Tuesday rather than meaning this coming Tuesday.

All sorts of little miscommunications can happen from region to region if you spend enough time in them.

The southeast would be the southeast ai would think. True we don’t usually say southeast as a region, but it seems pretty self explanatory that the OP must mean states like GA and SC. They are in the southeastern part of the US. I don’t know why you are being so critical. Maybe the OP actually simply means the south, or deep south, and doesn’t know that automatically excludes the southwest, but we don’t need to pretend it is impossible to know basically what states he is referrring to. We have at least a vague idea and can clarify it with the OP. I used to get confused when southerners call MI a northern state and lumped in MI with Vermont and New Jersey. I always referred to MI as a midwestern state, Jersey is northeast and Vermont is New England.

@linguaphile True, the south is the closest to the King’s English (I personally would say more in terms of dialect than accent, would you agree?) but it also sometimes seems like it is the farthest from it. Brits almost always pick on a southern accent as being an American accent to make fun of. Have you ever watched Top Gear?

JLeslie's avatar

Burough not burrough, and sorry for the other typos in the above answer.

ucme's avatar

I didn’t intend to answer this question, but it’d be remiss of me not to now that @JLeslie sent it my way.
There’s a huge variety of American accents which differ enormously, just like anywhere else really & most sound okay to me, a few are twangy & grate a little.
It’s more the words people use that irritate rather than any accent, I can’t stand the use of “right now” usually inserted at the end of a sentence for no good reason.
Lots of Brits have picked up that habit & it makes me want to punch them in the genitals.

JLeslie's avatar

Haha. I use right now all the time. I only use it with my husband though. He’ll tell me some errand he wants me to do, and I always clarify with, “right now?”

ucme's avatar

If you heard it over here though, spoken with a regional accent, entirely fake & just sounds twee.
“Ooh, i’m so annoyed right now”shut the fuck up already!!
See, there’s another one, “already” ...arrgghhh!

JLeslie's avatar

I’m pretty sure I use already in that way now and then. LOL. Although, I’m more likely to just stick with shut the fuck up; it seems sufficient in most circumstances. My husband tends to say to me, “you have to stop talking.” Or, simply, “stop talking.” As in, I’ll go ‘round the bend if I have to listen to your voice for one more second right now.

trailsillustrated's avatar

Love them. Sounds like Jimmy Stewart. Years ago was in Alabama and believe it or not, the similarities between that accent and australian was very surprising. I love america.

ucme's avatar

@JLeslie Sounds like he could use a “wife remote” useful for hitting mute or even pause.

JLeslie's avatar

@ucme He has been known to aim the TV remote at me.

OpryLeigh's avatar

Here in the UK we grow up with TV shows and films from the US and so the (generic) American accent is very familiar to us. I tend to like most American accents I hear, the only one that grates on me a bit is the California rich girl type (I can’t think of any other way to describe it, sorry, but Paris Hilton is a good example.) I love the New York-area accents (especially the Jewish-New Yorker maybe I’m a bit biased here (!) or Italian-New Yorker). I also like most Southern accents that I have heard. I am going to Texas and Tennessee this year so I am looking forward to hearing the accents down there.

Like @ucme said, some of the language that is more common here now is very American. I was talking to a parent the other day who said that he thinks his kids watch too much American programmes on TV as they would say trash or garbage instead of bin and diaper instead of nappy!

OpryLeigh's avatar

@ucme I actually really like the use of “already” at the end of a sentence (like the way you used it above)!!

ucme's avatar

@Leanne1986 Yeah, that one’s not so bad, just used it for a giggle.
There’s definitely some americanisation going on with language though, like I say, the use of “right now” drives me nuts.
Be hilarious if Americans suddenly began tarkin arl geordie like, a meen haway, haddaway & shite man.

JLeslie's avatar

@ucme The Brits I know overuse the word “right” in general. Would you agree? They use it while they are thinking about something that was just said to them.

Honestly, I love a British accent and the various differences in vocabulary. I like the differences in the manh regions around the US also. Here is a very very old Q of mine – one of my favorites – about the different words and expression in the US.

OpryLeigh's avatar

@ucme Being a West Country lass I want to hear more ‘gurt lush’ on American TV programs!!!
@JLeslie I would agree with that observation about the word “right”. I think “like” is overused here and in the US.

JLeslie's avatar

I use like way too much. Some teen girls use it every other word. LOL.

mattbrowne's avatar

I like all accents, from San Diego to Dallas to New York to Dublin to Manchester to Glagow to Bangalore to Brisbane to Wellington. I hope I left no one out. I also like it when French people speak English.

ucme's avatar

@JLeslie Right :)
@Leanne1986 Ooh arr, theed sound like reet wazzocks.

Mama_Cakes's avatar

I love New York accents. All types of new york accents. I’m not a fan of southern accents. I would say that my least favorite accents are Chicago and Michigan accents. I love me a Boston accent.’ Californians sound just like me.

- Canadian here

JLeslie's avatar

@Mama_Cakes Wait. MI oftens sounds similar to Canadian accents. Not the same, I definitely can tell the difference, but similar. Do you find the MI accent too nasal? I would say that is the major difference.

Mama_Cakes's avatar

@JLeslie Words like pop said “pap”. Bob said “Bab”. The “a’s” sound different.

Tinyfaery and her wife came to visit N. and I. I couldn’t hear an accent at all.

JLeslie's avatar

@Mama_Cakes Yeah, I know what you mean. I hear that also. That sounds nasal to me.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther