Social Question

Pandora's avatar

Do politicians have to take psych evaluation tests?

Asked by Pandora (32436points) July 1st, 2013

Another post made me think about politicians taking psych eval tests and so I started to wonder if you have to take such a test to be a politician. I know when my brother-in-law was going to work embassy duty he had to take a psych test. He failed. He really isn’t crazy but I think he is a bit high strung. When I asked him why he had to take the test, he said because they had to make sure the pressure of the job and his environment didn’t make him a liability to the embassy.

When you hear the crap that comes out of some politicians mouths, you have to wonder if they have a sound mind. It really doesn’t seem like anyone gets mentally tested and if they did, why wouldn’t they get tested yearly. Should we trust important information to people not playing with a full deck?

I know people also working intelligence have to take psych test, so shouldn’t politicians?
I’m assuming that they do not but if they are, then who is giving these test? Feel free to have fun with this question but if someone really knows, than please answer.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

14 Answers

Coloma's avatar

LOL…great Q.!
I haven’t a clue, but I will be interested to find out.
Makes sense to me, but then again, sociopaths are smooth operators and could probably fool the best psych. professional, hell, look how god they are at lying to the population and each other.
Sociopaths are intelligent, clever, amazingly skilled at deceptive charm, lying and always have an angle, uh….sociopath = politician. haha

Pandora's avatar

@Coloma I’m sure there are ways they can pick out a sociopath. A profiler should be able to tell. Heck, I’m no profiler and yet I can tell when I see one running for office. Though most are egocentric and erratic like Sarah Palin.

Coloma's avatar

@Pandora Sometimes perhaps, but…they are infamous for beating polygraphs and charming their way out of situations. I’d say 50/50 odds, at best.

augustlan's avatar

They certainly should have to, but to the best of my knowledge, they don’t.

Pandora's avatar

@Coloma I’ll take those odds over not having them tested.

exnick's avatar

They don’t. A psych evaluation won’t help either since surveys and questionnaires are not an objective science and personality, thinking, and emotions cannot be directly measured. The psychologist will end up concluding from a subjective answer.

However, there are certain branches of psychology that might remedy that such as Behavioral neuroscience, Neuropsychology, Physiological psychology, Cognitive neuroscience but I would imagine to do this regularly would take a lot of time and the costs would be enormous.

Those Fmri machines are really good.

Pandora's avatar

@exnick Think of the cost of putting some cracker nut in the presidents chair. I thought there was a test where they compared sociopaths brain patterns or something like that? One test. Your brain looks normal you get to run. It doesn’t then you don’t.

exnick's avatar

Yeah, they examined the brains of serial killers. They did find differences that might be the cause of the behavior, but I don’t think its conclusive though. Btw, brain sizes are not important at all. It’s the “processor” of the brain that’s important. People use to make misogynistic arguments that women have smaller brains than men and that makes men more intelligent, but neuroscience has shown that although a woman’s brain is smaller than a mans, it actually has the same and possibly even more processing power than a man’s. However, men and women do think differently.

Schizophrenia, for example, can be observed clearly on the brain when under an mri machine.

Pachy's avatar

They should, but being psychopathic, they’d surely find ways to beat the tests.

Pandora's avatar

@Pandora They could easily afford these test if they just use 1/10th of what they spend on media coverage. I’m sure they have that all available in Bethesda. Since it is a military hospital, it won’t cost them that much.

Nullo's avatar

@Pandora Ah, but you’re asking them to a) take money from the war chest and b) risk them losing the campaign. A double-lose.

There are those who think that mental illness or sociopathy is a requirement, or perhaps even part of the definition, of politician.
The late Douglas Adams was of the opinion that running things was too important to leave to politicians, so they mostly get elected to keep people from realizing that they don’t do anything. So it was with Zaphod Beeblebrox.

Pandora's avatar

Nah, I don’t think it should be a requirement. I mean we have let the clowns run the circus for some time and all we are left with is a bunch of crying children, lots of elephant and donkey shit, and stale old popcorn. We aren’t too far from them releasing the lions on the crowd.

Nullo's avatar

What you need is a candidate who undergoes and successfully passing an evaluation as a campaign publicity stunt, and for that to catch on.

Pandora's avatar

@Nullo GA! LMAO That would work.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther