General Question

elbanditoroso's avatar

"raj" and "rosh" - any etymological connection?

Asked by elbanditoroso (33553points) September 2nd, 2013

“raj”, in Sanskrit and various other languages, means royalty, leader, kingdom, etc. It also appears to be an honorific in some Asian languages.

“Rosh” in Hebrew, means “head” as “primary” or “first” as in Rosh Hashanah (the ‘head of the year, New Year’s Day) or Rosh Hamemshalah (Head of Government). It’s also very closely related to the Arabic “Ras” in both sound and meaning.

And there is “roi”, French, for “king” or “royalty”, which was derived and descended from the Latin ‘rex”.

My question – is there an etymological connection between them? It seems to me that the similar in sound and meeting strongly suggests it, but I haven’t found anything that agrees with me. Possible?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

11 Answers

drhat77's avatar

Awesome. I’m the most amateur linguist there is, and to that, I say, sure seems so!

DominicX's avatar

It seems unlikely.

The Proto-Semitic root *raʾš is the source of “rosh” and the words meaning “head” in Semitic languages. The Proto-Indo-European root *h₃reg is source of the words for “king” and “rule” in Indo-European languages, hence “rex”, “regal”, “regular”, “roi”, “rey”, “raj”, “raja”, etc.

I don’t really see the ”š” from Semitic or the laryngeal from the IE having a common ancestor. The “r” is really the only sound the roots have in common and that could be chocked up to coincidence, especially since the meanings are not identical. It is interesting though :)

gailcalled's avatar

( Hey, Dom. Chalked up toit is always interesting.)

DominicX's avatar

^Right, that. Of course. :P Something I only heard people say; never really thought about how it was spelled.

morphail's avatar

There are always coincidental similarities in sound and meaning across languages. But it’s not enough just to point this out to show a relationship, you need to show exactly how the sounds are related. Many related words are not similar due to the many sound and meaning changes, for instance Sanskrit “raj”, Latin “rex”, English “right”.

gailcalled's avatar

@morphail: This is why I love Fluther.

DominicX's avatar

@morphail GAs. Awesome links :)

Just wanted to add that predictable sound change patterns in IE can show how “hreg” becomes “rex” or “raj” or “right” or something like that.

“hreg-s”—> “regs”—> “rex”
“hreg-tos”—> “rehtaz”—> “reht”—> “right” (also “rectify”, etc.)

Showing those intermediate steps is how you’d prove that words are related. And steps like that work across many different words in the various languages and can become predictable. If that can’t be shown for certain words, it’s more likely that the similarities are coincidence.

Strauss's avatar

~The same relationship between “raj” and “rosh” can also be seen between ”¡Hola!” and “Hollah!”

gailcalled's avatar

And challah bread?

Strauss's avatar

@gailcalled Oh, I thought hollah bread was the new soul food!

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther