Can a shoe repair shop fix these issues?

I completely understand your reluctance to give up on a pair of shoes you really like. A good shop should be able to make most if not all these repairs but be prepared, it’ll be expensive.

I’m going to disagree with @Pachyderm_In_The_Room on this topic. If the footwear is damaged “beyond commercial repair” the best shops will refuse to do the work because it makes their repairs cost more than the value of the items when they were new, and few customers will pay for that. So they end up eating the cost and wasting their time. Good shops won’t do that. They won’t waste their time and money in the first place, and they may not even want to serve you if you bring them junk and expect them to perform miracles. They’ll act – rightly – as if you have no idea what you’re even asking, or that you can’t tell good quality from bad, and they won’t want an association with you for that reason. I’ve seen that happen.

Secondly, some goods are so cheap because they are shoddy to begin with (pun not intended), and high-quality repair shops can see that at a glance. They may not waste their time even if you pay them up front, because they consider it a waste of their time and talent even if you are paying.

Some broken goods cannot be fixed unless you are prepared to pay far more than the thing is really worth – assuming you will pay, and the base materials are at least whole enough to attach repair parts to – and even if the repairs are made and paid for, the look and feel may be so different that you’ll wish you hadn’t wasted your time and money in the first place.

You will find nothing here but conflicting speculative answers. Call a few cobblers in your area, and ask them.

I took my husbands shoes in once to get a new heel on both of his favorite shoes. They said the cost would be 60 dollars. The shoe only cost 90. So I looked up the brand on-line and found the exact same shoe on sale for 80.
Have you tried looking up the shoe on-line to see if it is still being made? There will be more sizes available on-line than what you may find in the store.
Good luck.

Right on, @glacial. Easy to see how to made it to the Mansion. :-)

Nothing to add except to also suggest going to a shoe repair shop or two and asking for their opinion and pricing.

I have two pairs of initially inexpensive Mary Janes that I have kept for about 25 years with new heels and buckles on periodically. I just like them.

@Pandora unfortunately the combat boots were an online purchase and I can’t seem to find the exact same ones anymore :( These I actually would be willing to buy again because they were only $50 but it’s not even in my amazon orders list for some reason; the company may be gone now. The other two are from about 3 years back and were both around $145 when purchased. Can’t find them ANYWHERE :(

My main thing is just seeing if some stuff is even possible. I don’t know what shoe repair places do besides replace heel tips. I suppose I’ll have to make a bunch of calls today….....

@hummingbug3 If you can, it would be really helpful for you to actually bring the shoes in for them to tell you what they can do and give you an estimate. But you can certainly narrow down the likely suspects first.