@Skaggfacemutt You wrote: We know so little about the human mind, how can any of us profess to know how to “fix it”, especially when you are talking about “mood disorders.”
Actually, I believe we know quite a lot about the mind. The fallacy that we don’t is dangerous. It leads some individuals to think the mind is some type of supernatural force operating above the realm accessible by empirical inquiry.
The mind is real. It can be studied, and indeed has been done so since the time of Socrates and Plato.
The fact that illnesses of the brain can be diagnosed and treated is wonderful. It allows me, a person with bipolar disorder type one and generalized anxiety disorder, to live a more balanced life. Without the medicine I take and the psychotherapy I receive, I would not be able to function on any reasonable level and would be locked in an institution.
Why do you place the words mood disorders inside quotation marks? The implication is that you believe they aren’t real. I can give firsthand testimony that they are quite unpleasantly real.
You also wrote: It doesn’t take a doctor to know that anything you take that alters your state of mind can’t be a good thing. What if the state of mind is sick to begin with? Would you deny a sick person the medicine that is going to help? If you catch a cold, do you take anti-histamines? If a person has diabetes, shouldn’t they take insulin?
I take medicine, because of the bipolar disorder I have. It helps me. Before I was diagnosed and before I was given the medications, my life was awful to say the least. I would stop short of calling my life “good” at present, but I am able to take care of my daily needs.
Your sentence “That is, if you don’t commit a mass shooting or something first.” is infuriating. It’s obvious you believe persons with mental illness and those being given medication for it are homicidal. I am a Hawaii Certified Peer Specialist in mental health and work with people just like me who are mentally ill. We are no more dangerous than any other person.
I am very sorry to read your sister has such trouble. I can sympathize with her that mental illness is horrible. The misunderstanding of and stigma against mental illness are tremendous burdens to bear. I understand what it’s like to have members of one’s own family ridicule me for what they can’t see and assume doesn’t exist somehow. My father has all but laughed in my face and has overtly told me I’m not living my life right. I cannot begin to express the deep pain that causes me. When people close to us reject us, it hurts beyond words.