Lip balm. I usually buy 2 or 3 at a time. My lips get chapped very easily, so I use it every day.
Wet wipes. We have a lot of young ‘uns in our family and they get very sticky, and they make other things very sticky.
Cheaters reading glasses. I get them at the dollar store, and have one pair in each room of my house where I might read a book, look at the computer, try to see the directions on a bottle of medication, read a label on a food package, plus another set for my purse, one in my car and one in my friend’s house. I tend to lose them, and every now and then one of the little screws comes out and I find out the hole is stripped, so I can’t fix ‘em.
Toilet paper, both for wiping down low, and for blowin’ up higher (we all have allergies).
Those little plastic containers that you get at Mexican restaurants, for salsa. I love salsa. At least those are recyclable.
The only thing I can think of for the takes a long time to use it up is coffee filters. I drink instant, my folks don’t drink coffee, so I only bust out coffee filters on Christmas and Thanksgiving, or when I’m straining yogurt to make This
Oh, and plastic forks and knives. They always give those to you when you get Mexican take-out, but I always eat it at home and use my regular flatware. So I just throw them in a ziplock bag, and if I ever need them for a picnic, then I use them.