General Question

justin5824's avatar

Why does an ISP route this way?

Asked by justin5824 (196points) November 9th, 2014

So this is a traceroute from one of Bell Canada’s core routers in Montreal. (http://www.as577.net/en/page/lg.html)

So if I’m trying to get to a server in Halifax, from Montreal (http://www.ednet.ns.ca/), why would the traffic get routed to Toronto (core4-toronto21_POS0–0–2–0.net.bell.ca) and back to what’s likely the same data centre it started at in Montreal (ae8.bx01.mtrl.pq.aliant.net [Aliant is a subsidiary of Bell Canada])

traceroute to doeweb.ednet.ns.ca (142.227.127.125), 30 hops max, 38 byte packets
1 agg2-montreal02_ge11–1-7 (184.150.172.61) 0.238 ms 0.174 ms 0.156 ms
2 core4-montreal02_xe0–8-2–0_core.net.bell.ca (64.230.170.253) 12.380 ms 11.656 ms 8.346 ms
MPLS Label=18285 CoS=5 TTL=255 S=0
3 tcore4-toronto21_POS0–0-2–0.net.bell.ca (64.230.147.122) 12.769 ms 10.718 ms 12.369 ms
MPLS Label=17056 CoS=5 TTL=255 S=0
4 tcore4-torontoxn_HundredGigE0–12-0–0.net.bell.ca (64.230.50.19) 7.506 ms 8.281 ms 7.851 ms
MPLS Label=16314 CoS=5 TTL=255 S=0
5 dis3-torontoxn_10–0-0.net.bell.ca (64.230.97.139) 7.345 ms 8.236 ms 7.352 ms
6 67.69.211.22 (67.69.211.22) 7.299 ms 21.734 ms 25.701 ms
7 ae8.bx01.mtrl.pq.aliant.net (207.231.227.122) 7.236 ms 7.224 ms 8.041 ms
8 ae9.cr02.mctn.nb.aliant.net (207.231.227.125) 19.627 ms 19.607 ms 19.625 ms
9 be3.cr01.mctn.nb.aliant.net (142.166.185.137) 20.244 ms 20.234 ms 20.006 ms
10 be4.cr01.hlfx.ns.aliant.net (142.166.129.70) 23.756 ms 23.589 ms 23.675 ms
11 xe-1-0-0.gw01.hlfx.ns.aliant.net (142.176.53.115) 24.398 ms xe-0-0-0.gw01.hlfx.ns.aliant.net (142.176.53.99) 23.109 ms xe-1-0-0.gw01.hlfx.ns.aliant.net (142.176.53.115) 23.088 ms
12 142.176.119.18 (142.176.119.18) 23.143 ms 23.146 ms 23.148 ms
13 * * *
14 216.83.21.155 (216.83.21.155) 23.285 ms 23.265 ms 23.218 ms
15 eoc.ednet.ns.ca (142.227.51.30) 23.406 ms 23.371 ms 23.414 ms

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

2 Answers

talljasperman's avatar

Maybe the police took over your site? Or hacker’s from China?

jerv's avatar

You can’t go through the NSA data collectors without a few detours :D

Seriously though, routing depends on traffic and where the fast lines are. For some things, it really is quicker to go the long way, just as 10 miles of highway is faster than 10 blocks of stop-and-go traffic despite being a longer distance.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther