I’ve been involved with both ends of the spectrum. Looking back, I realize that someone’s character is so much more important than their intellectual ability (or lack thereof).
One is basically born with whatever intellectual ability they have. Yes, it can be upped slightly depending upon the influences in their childhood. But some kids are just naturally smarter than others and some aren’t. That’s the way the bell curve works.
But character is formed from the thousands of choices both large and small that one makes at each fork in the road.
Bernie Madoff was, by all accounts, a much smarter than average guy.
But he was morally bankrupt. I doubt his wife was thrilled to have married him when all was said and done.
During my last year of college I was dating a really nice guy. He was smart enough but I knew he wasn’t as smart as I since I consistently beat him in Chess.
And he really didn’t have much intellectual curiosity. He was fairly content with the status quo.
However, he was rock solid in terms of his valuea like trustworthiness, honesty, caring about people and just being an all around really good guy.
He was in the Air Force at the time but was planning to go to Seminary afterwards to be a Pastor.
During my first yr. of teaching he came to visit me for a long weekend and on the last night proposed to me. It caught me totally off guard and I turned him down saying I just wasn’t ready. The biggest problem was that I was very happy teaching right where I was. If I married him, it meant moving all the way to Texas (from NY) and eventually being a Pastor’s wife.
I just couldn’t get enthused about any of that. I certainly liked him but didn’t know him long enough to make a lifelong love commitment. Perhaps at a later point in time…
But after some of the really smart and smug jerks I subsequently ran into while dating, in hindsight I probably should have married him.
Things look much different in maturity than they do in youth.