Social Question

Earthbound_Misfit's avatar

What book has surprised you?

Asked by Earthbound_Misfit (13177points) March 9th, 2015

My husband bought me a book called ‘Between Us: Words of wisdom and wit from women of letters’ for Christmas. It’s a collection of letters from Australian women and was curated by Marieke Hardy and Michaela McGuire. I’d never heard of it and had no idea what to expect. Surprisingly, I’m really enjoying it. Each letter is only a few pages long so it doesn’t demand a huge investment of sustained time. The surprising thing is how touching, funny and warm the letters are. Each one is different and many make me think about some aspect of my own life or teach me about culture or make me consider the way we view the world and life.

What book have you bought or been given that has surprised you when you’ve delved into its pages? What did you expect when you bought it or received it, and why has it surprised you?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

21 Answers

Adirondackwannabe's avatar

Is this a feel good question or is it okay to bring in a downer answer?

Earthbound_Misfit's avatar

It’s perfectly okay to answer with a ‘downer answer’. Some books surprise us in a negative way.

Adirondackwannabe's avatar

I’m reading The Great War For Civilisation, The Conquest of the Middle East, Robert Fisk. It’s full of hate and brutality, so be forewarned. As a counterweight I came across Christopher Moore a while ago. An absolute Wildman. He’s hysterical.

Earthbound_Misfit's avatar

@Adirondackwannabe, The Conquest for the Middle East sounds as though it would include a lot of hate and brutality (from various factions). Why is it surprising?

Similarly, Christopher Moore, what is his book about? Tell me more (Moore?).

Adirondackwannabe's avatar

@Earthbound_Misfit The depth and the intensity of the hatred and the cruelty is beyond anything I ever thought existed, on the plane he presents it. This stuff is beyond me. Laughs, the first Christopher Moore book I read was The Stupidest Angel. It’s a Christmas tale.

Earthbound_Misfit's avatar

Thank you. Both sound like books I’d find interesting.

Winter_Pariah's avatar

For the longest time my mother tried to get me to read Jane Eyre. Having already read Wuthering Heights and REALLY not liking it, I refused for a while before finally relenting and I prepared for a snooze-fest.

It is now one of the few books I have read more than 3 times.

Espiritus_Corvus's avatar

Me & Lee: How I Came to Know, Love and Lose Lee Harvey Oswald, by Judyth Vary.

Don’t laugh. It’s a ridiculous title, I know. I laughed when I read it, too. I swear to god, I didn’t buy it. Somebody left it on the boat. Talk about creepy. Some crazy woman wrote a love story about her supposed affair with Lee Harvey Oswald—and she actually got published!! The gods must be crazy. Then it occurred to me that it might be a novel. But it’s not. She’s serious.

To preface: I lost interest in anything concerning the Kennedy assassination ages ago. Like most people my age, I just gave up trying to sort out all the bullshit and a trance-like ennui permanently set in. Mention it to me and my eyes immediately glaze over. But one day, after this book lay around getting mouldy for a few months, I finally snuck a peek at the thing. Within the first few paragraphs I discovered that Vary went to high school near where I did in Florida—only she just happened to have the highest student IQ in the state at the time. OK, that was mildly interesting. And like me, she spent time in medical research—only she was doing it on her own at home in her bedroom complete with rats when she was fifteen. Her work was recognized by Dr. Alton Ochsner of Tulane and Roswell Park Cancer Institute before she even got out of high school. She was getting guidance from two Nobel Prize winners in biochemistry before she went on her first date.

I kept reading.

I soon found that the amount of source documentation she provides to back her claims concerning Oswald is almost overwhelming; the footnotes take up at least a third of the book’s text. She provides photos of many of the documents listed. There are two extensive Appendices and the book is very well indexed. Vary evidently never threw away a scrap of paper, a receipt, a movie ticket, a streetcar chit, a letter, or a paystub during the entire time she lived in New Orleans. She even provides photo copies of Oswald’s paystubs going back to 1961.

Her story is amazing and convincing. The idea that Oswald may not have been the shooter, or even on the fourth floor of the book depository at the time of the shooting is actually, to me, for the first time ever, believable—thanks to Vary’s obsessive documentation. Equally important was the strange cancer research Vary was recruited into by deception at the time at Tulane University, Charity Hospital and the Ochsner Clinic in New Orleans—and how it all tied in with Oswald associates Jack Ruby, Guy Bannister, Carlos Marcello, Clay Shaw, E. Howard Hunt, Ochsner and some important medical personnel who were murdered after the assassination, including David Ferrie and one of the most important cancer researchers of the time, Dr. Mary Sherman, with whom Vary had worked closely. Vary now lives in Norway and I’ve emailed her. She’s doing well, but misses her kids. This book has a lousy title that appeals to the wrong audience entirely.

And it did surprised the hell out of me.

Mimishu1995's avatar

The Oxford Murders. It was surprisingly horrible. I’m a fan of mystery and a lot of people recommended me this book. That and the fact that there is a movie based on it made me believe that it would be fantastic. But look what it brought: without spoiling everything, I’d say that you can guess who’s the murderer right when the first murder happens. The rest of the book just tells a ridiculous reasoning process of the protagonist and a series of random evens that contribute to the suspense (in a bad way). Too many random events for a good murder mystery.

ucme's avatar

Ron Jeremy: An Autobiography…twas a pop-up book, nearly had my eye out.

filmfann's avatar

@ucme Well, I am glad your mouth wasn’t agape

ucme's avatar

@filmfann Yeah, woulda been a severe blow for sure.

cazzie's avatar

In my lifetime, I have thrown exactly two books across the room in disgust. The first was The Book of Mormon and the second was The Da Vinci Code. I obviously don’t read enough. Correction… There was another I simply put down and couldn’t finish and that was ‘Sybil’ and while I may not have thrown that across the room, I put it down with some equal measure.

No, wait… I have to edit again! I also threw ‘Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus’ across the room! Oh, what a day that was!

dappled_leaves's avatar

@cazzie Any indie bookseller worth his salt would have steered you clear of every one of those. Get to know your booksellers!

cazzie's avatar

@dappled_leaves you are assuming those books came to me from one particular source… Umm… no. Also… I don’t have a ‘bookseller’...... they are on a par to drug pushers in my mind. I would rather explore with my own mind, thank you very much.

dappled_leaves's avatar

@cazzie Then it appears my advice is even more needed!

cazzie's avatar

If you can guess what is currently on my nightstand to read… I’ll take your advice.

dappled_leaves's avatar

Nah, that’s not my business anymore.

cazzie's avatar

(I think @dappled_leaves forgets how old I am and that the exposure to those books was over 20 years.) there are more good books chosen by me…..

dappled_leaves's avatar

(I think @cazzie is taking me too seriously.)

Earthbound_Misfit's avatar

@Espiritus_Corvus, I can see why that book wouldn’t have appealed and also why it was so fascinated when you picked it up and read it. Really interesting. Thank you.

@cazzie, but were you really surprised that those books were so bad?

@dappled_leaves, I’d love to have a local bookseller. They’re becoming rare as hen’s teeth here. I tend to buy online mostly. I miss those hours spent mooching around bookshelves in a book shop.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther