@Dutchess_III: “If a guy is so moronic and jerkful as to comment on how sexy he finds other women, that’s a pretty big clue as to how he will react if “confronted,” even calmly, about his actions”
Most couples I know have things about their relationship that work for them but wouldn’t work for me. Who am I to say what works for each couple. I repeat, who am I to say.
But do you know who is to say? The OP. And do you know what she has “said” so far. Nothing, which = acceptance.
People are not mind readers. And pretending to be ok with something while you’re not is dishonest. It clearly hurts her feelings. But this is the most important part – right now, there is no evidence that it is his intention to hurt her feelings. He might be devastated to learn that she has been hurt by this.
My sister-in-law hates dark chocolate. When she started dating her husband, he would buy her find the finest dark chocolate for her on valentine’s day. But she never told him. They’ve been married for 16 years, and he still spends $100 each year on chocolate she doesn’t like. But do you know who knows about this? He doesn’t, but I do. That’s disgusting. Note: their marriage is a nightmare, and it is no wonder. She can’t even be honest about something as simple as a taste in chocolate.
I have never lied to my wife. If she does or says something that hurts my feelings, I tell her. And she does the same. If I felt that I couldn’t tell her, then it would mean that I married the wrong person. That would be enough to end the relationship immediately.
Lying and dishonesty is about as bad as it gets (morally and for the health of relationships). Whatever the particulars are of problems between people, if someone isn’t being honest, that must be addressed first. The rest is just not relevant.
Again, if she goes to him and he goes all fucktard, then he’s probably an asshole. Either way, the relationship doesn’t seem to be built for longevity if hurt feelings cannot be expressed.