Does this comment even make any sense?
From this article where a car fell on a teen.
”....Ray suffered broken ribs and a bruised kidney, said Dr. Richard Miller of the Vanderbilt Trauma Center.
“He had probably crushed his kidney,” Miller said. “And so his kidney was torn and bruised.””
What does he mean “probably” crushed his kidney? And when something is crushed, isn’t it normally torn and bruised?
Observing members:
0
Composing members:
0
7 Answers
There are lots of ways a kidney can be momentarily crushed. Not all of them lead to bruising or being torn.
Probably a better word would have been “compressed”. “Crushed” carries a connotation of permanent compression.
They don’t know until he gets seen by a doctor.
A simple response to the question is:
You can’t make sense out of nonsense.
A nicer response would acknowledge that people habitually speak casually; we don’t pay attention to what we say or we assume the listener knows what we mean.
If he hadn’t seen a doctor yet @talljasperman, how would the guy know if the kidney was torn and bruised?
I agree @SABOTEUR. Reporting and editing is so sloppy any more.
No, it was a “Dr. Richard Miller of the Vanderbilt Trauma Center.”
Answer this question data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6ef99/6ef9935b4bc98727abd12a62124e0175d39dd885" alt="sending..."