@flo I haven’t addressed it explicitly, simply because you already know the answer.
“Once you become an elected official or any government employee you have to act like a robot? You lose your right to refuse to do something and make noise the way she is doing?”
Change those question marks to periods and you’re pretty close to the truth. It’s also why I relayed a little something about my own time on Uncle Sam’s payroll. But lets see what Kentucky state law has to say
22.020 Official misconduct in the first degree.
(1) A public servant is guilty of official misconduct in the first degree when, with intent to obtain or confer a benefit or to injure another person or to deprive another person of a benefit, he knowingly:
. .(a) Commits an act relating to his office which constitutes an unauthorized exercise of his official functions; or
. .(b) Refrains from performing a duty imposed upon him by law or clearly inherent in the nature of his office; or
. .(c) Violates any statute or lawfully adopted rule or regulation relating to his office.
(2) Official misconduct in the first degree is a Class A misdemeanor.
A civil servant refusing to perform their duty due to personal beliefs IS an explicitly codified criminal offense that is punishable by law. Once you take the job, you forfeit any and all right to say, “I won’t do this because it conflicts with my beliefs.” as a condition of your employment. I could probably say that a few dozen other ways as well just to drive the point home, but I think I’ve made it clear enough to understand on an intellectual level that working for the government deprives you of some off your freedoms and rights.
And it’s not that those rights are taken from you either; you willingly agreed to the terms and conditions of employment when you took the job. Hell, you requested it by filling out the application! And unlike civilian jobs, the duties, obligations, and restrictions are outlined quite well in a publicly accessible manner. I am just a regular citizen yet I managed to pull up a statute from Kentucky State Law in about four seconds of Googling.
“If you go by that, then no one would ever run for election. That is not practical.”
Firemen also know that getting burned to death in the line of duty happens. Not every time, but often enough to be considered a potential risk inherent in the job. People also get hit by trucks, but many of us still cross streets and use sidewalks despite that inherent risk.
Also, the compensation packages tend to be pretty decent. A County Clerk in Rowan County has an $80,000/yr salary. Given what many jobs pay, I think it worth a little risk to pull in that sort of dough. I mean, that’s more than most dual-income households earn, so it seems practical to want that if you are willing to live with the conditions of employment that warrant such generosity.
When Kim Davis said, “I never imagined a day like this would come, where I would be asked to violate a central teaching of Scripture and of Jesus Himself regarding marriage.”, she proved herself to be an idiot with no knowledge of history or government, and the fact that she got elected despite that makes me wonder about Kentucky. Just as firemen get burned and machinists get metal chips in their clothing, the long and well-publicized push for same-sex marriages along with the growing number of states passing legislature to allow it points to a risk that Kentucky and/or the feds could change the laws in a way that Davis found objectionable.
Anyone who has been exposed to any sort of journalism or mass media in this country in the last decade or so has seen/heard quite a bit about same-sex marriage. They have also heard that certain states have changed their laws to allow it. Anyone politically savvy enough to win an election (or pass 10th grade Social Studies) knows that when certain cases are appealed high enough to reach the Supreme Court, that can lead to changes in federal law as well.
The risk was foreseeable. If Davis did not foresee it herself, that is of no consequence; all that matters is that she could have, just as I could’ve foreseen my soda spilling on the rug when my cat jumped up on the table. It may not be something you think about, but it’s something that shouldn’t be a surprise when it happens unless you have both no memory and no concept of cause-and-effect.
Maybe the risk is only actually seen in hindsight, but that does not mean that lack of due diligence beforehand is a legitimate defense. That damp spot on my floor isn’t because my cat is a malicious little bastard; it’s because I didn’t think my cat would wake up from his nap and jump up on the table. Likewise, if Kim Davis been concerned over the possibility that she may be asked to do things she found objectionable if she became County Clerk, she could’ve done a little research into what duties were expected of a County Clerk and what her rights were. Just as I inspect and test drive every car I buy before I actually buy it, a little “look before you leap” can save you from a metaphorical pair of broken legs.