Social Question

filmfann's avatar

What if we discover a threatening alien civilization that lives 1,500 light years away?

Asked by filmfann (52455points) October 19th, 2015

This question about the possibility of an alien lifeform possibly constructing a Dyson Sphere around a star, referred to as KIC 8462852.
The star is 1,500 light years away.
Let’s say that new efforts to locate alien communication are successful, and we determine that the civilization is a dangerous threat if they identify us as a life form.
What do we do?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

39 Answers

janbb's avatar

Send Donald Trump on a mission to negotiate with them.

ARE_you_kidding_me's avatar

I’m not worried unless they can travel faster than light.

Berserker's avatar

I do wonder. I don’t think our military is equipped to fight things other than humans. We do have weapons that can severely damage the planet though…have no idea if you can send those into outer space anshit however.

elbanditoroso's avatar

Not a damn thing. If they have the technology and ability to travel here and then attack us, then they are light years (pun intended) ahead of us in their military technology.

We don’t stand a chance.

May as well sit back and enjoy the show.

WillWorkForChocolate's avatar

We call Bill Pullman, Will Smith, Jeff Goldblum, and Randy Quaid for help.

janbb's avatar

@WillWorkForChocolate I think Randy Quaid may be unavailable.

WillWorkForChocolate's avatar

@janbb Nah, if the need is great enough, I’m sure he’d be given a pass! Especially if he were willing to fly up the blowhole of an alien spaceship again.

ragingloli's avatar

Then you at least know that there is a threat, and have time to prepare at least some sort of defence.
Which is better than not knowing and being surprised by an alien invasion fleet with no preparation.

Hawaii_Jake's avatar

Let’s invite them to tea.

Hypocrisy_Central's avatar

We certainly would not be praying, so I guess we will be partying and boinking like bunnies until the bitter end. ~~~

flutherother's avatar

Switch off everything electrical, keep very quiet and hope to God they don’t notice we are here.

Hawaii_Jake's avatar

Perhaps they’ll stop being threatening, if we show them our collection of kitten pictures on the Internet.

ARE_you_kidding_me's avatar

At least we will probably stop fighting each other

Rarebear's avatar

Well, consider that there is a 3000 year time lag in communication, I wouldn’t be too worried about it.

Blondesjon's avatar

We send in the INS.

DrasticDreamer's avatar

Might not be a Dyson Sphere, but it would be massive, whatever it is.

But like @elbanditoroso said, if they were threatening and they came here, there isn’t anything we could do. We can’t even imagine the kind of technology it would take for them to make the trip. The most we could do is hope that they’re peaceful.

kritiper's avatar

We do nothing. If they decided to come after us, it would take time for them to prepare, and a whole lot of time for them to get here. By that time, we’ll be extinct. And if they still come, they can deal with the superbugs that killed us.

ucme's avatar

Shit bricks.

filmfann's avatar

Let’s say that we find a Dyson Sphere (which is ridiculous). The technology required would mean they can travel beyond light speed. Our only chance would be to advance our technology, and hope they didn’t notice our communication signals. We would have to mask or cease television broadcasts, unless they are over cable.
Let’s also remember that our communication signals won’t reach them for 1,430 years.

gorillapaws's avatar

We should focus our collective global resources on spreading our population to other planets/stars so we can’t be annihilated in one attack. It’s unlikely that we’ll have the technology to defend ourselves from a direct bombardment by the time they reach us, but it may be possible that we could fire off some ships with human embryos on ice to distant galaxies, and possibly to hide in other corners of our own solar system until the coast is clear.

Here2_4's avatar

Send them a Trojan horse of gifts. Infect everything with viruses.

stanleybmanly's avatar

Threatening implies that they are ahead of us-far ahead of us technologically. I strongly suspect that any civilization that advances significantly beyond our own will not survive to achieve such a feat if saddled with the primitive belligerent social impulses which afflict us. If you think about it, the one consequence neglected in the glories of our technological advance is that it daily grows increasingly more possible for ever smaller numbers of us through a growing variety of means to destroy us all. The day will arrive when one defective individual will have and use the means to end us all.

stanleybmanly's avatar

I think if there are civilizations in our galaxy capable of interstellar travel, they would in all likelihood take one look at what we’re doing here, and quarrantine us on the spot. There’s no doubt in my mind that the second it appears there’s a chance that we might escape this solar system, we will be rudely informed that violent self destructive barbarians are not allowed to spread their contagion throughout the stars.

Pandora's avatar

Back away slowly and if that doesn’t work, use CG videos of us blinking planets that threaten us out of existence. Maybe they won’t know what Videos are and will think they should stay away from us.

Pandora's avatar

We send a probe that has a video showing that our planet blew up. A kind of farewell to the universe, showing how we tried to save the planet but was unsuccessful and so all we could do was send out a time capsule of a civilization that once existed.

msh's avatar

Tell them were are all of ISIS, the best and brightest being on this list- (leaders)
Take them with you for studies and live vivisection.

WillWorkForChocolate's avatar

“Umm…if we built this large, wooden badger…”

kritiper's avatar

@filmfann I found out some time ago that our radio and television signals peter out before they really get too far from Earth, so “they” shouldn’t notice any.
@stanleybmanly Have you been watching “The Day the Earth Stood Still” again???

rojo's avatar

We would immediately begin to worry about them coming to Earth without the proper paperwork and taking jobs away from Earthlings. Most of them will be rapists and murderers sent here by their own society as a way to cleanse up their own world.
Politicians will immediately begin to tell us what they would do to solve the problem if we would only elect them to office. This includes such offices as city councilmen, and mayor and other offices which couldn’t actually do a damn thing about illegal space immigration even if they owned a gun (and the appropriate CC permit).

Here2_4's avatar

We should set out a big welcome party in the desert with doves to set free and promise a lasting friendship.

filmfann's avatar

@Here2_4. Extra lurve for the Mars Attacks reference.

basstrom188's avatar

Send in immigration and customs

basstrom188's avatar

A Dyson Sphere does that mean we might be attacked by a giant vacuum cleaner?

ARE_you_kidding_me's avatar

Just by overpriced gimmicky consumer electronics.

Brian1946's avatar

If Bush is elected, the US will respond by invading Iran. ;-)

stanleybmanly's avatar

@filmfann what’s the name of the guy whose singing caused the invaders’ heads to explode? My own head’s close to blowing up trying to remember that man’s name. For years compilations of his stuff were hawked on late night tv.

Brian1946's avatar

@stanleybmanly

The artist with the Martian-head exploding falsetto was Slime Whitman.

stanleybmanly's avatar

Slim thanks!

Here2_4's avatar

I saw those commercials a lot. It made MY head explode, and I’m from Earth.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther