Raising a little girl, there’s certainly pressure from both sides. There’s pressure from myself and my wife to raise a strong, independent young lady who values herself and the things we think are important like intelligence or empathy. There’s pressure to do right by my mother, who was so strong and able I never knew women were “supposed” to be less until much later. The pressure from the overly feminine side comes from just about everywhere else. The toys, just about every interaction with people in public, the shows, the clothes, the haircut place, pretty much everything. Everyone means well, it’s just the norm, so it feels like it needs to be countered.
I try to tell myself when we do it, it’s not “pressure” it’s “guidance” but I’m not sure there’s a difference. I’m sure the “guidance” will increase in the future when the stakes seem a little higher. Maybe guidance turns to pressure as she becomes her own person? I don’t know.
I wonder how I’d do as a father if my daughter comes home one day and tells me she wants to compete in toddler beauty pageants or something. Part of me thinks the encouragement is what’s important and I should support her, part of me would rather she joins a cult. It seems unlikely, but she just turned 4 and after being an American Ninja Warrior and a galloping herd of unicorns with her friends the last two halloweens, this year it’s all about being a princess. I keep suggesting other things, but she’ll probably end up being a princess of some kind. If I’m honest, I guess part of me wonders if I’m failing to show her better role models than teenage girls who long for men’s love and pretty dresses.
So I guess I pressure her to give up girly things to some extent, or at least to check out the other options. Thinking it through, I wouldn’t try to talk her out of being an astronaut, robot, or broccoli.
I would imagine when she’s a teenager and starts making her own choices, independent of my sage counsel (:P) that may manifest as judgement of those that made different choices than she did. But I think that’s true of just about any choice, especially at that age.
As far as earning respect from men by rejecting feminine things. I think it’s a little more complex than that. There’s an imbalance where men are less likely to be accepted doing traditionally feminine things than women doing masculine things. I have a friend who says men want relationships with people they can understand and women want someone who understands them. I think it’s overly generalized, because of course there’s people on both sides, but summarizes traditional roles relationships (romantic, work, and friendship) pretty well.
So I think there’s a pressure to reject traditionally feminine things, but only as a counter to the constant assumption that young ladies are longing to be as girly as possible, if they just had the means.