Why couldn't Obi-Wan Kenobi interfere with Luke Skywalkers fight with Darth Vader?
Why? Also how could he interfere? Humor welcome.
Observing members:
0
Composing members:
0
10 Answers
Because that’s how the script was written.
Because Gerorge Lucas hasn’t had an original thought since 1968.
My guess is that being dead was probably an impediment to him being able to interfere.
Maybe he could. It’s unclear what powers a Force spirit has. But in both of the fights between Luke and Darth Vader, there’s more on the line than just winning the duel. There’s also the war between the light and dark sides of the Force going on within Luke’s heart and mind. In the first fight, it’s Darth Vader tempting Luke to join the dark side. In the second fight, it’s Palpatine. That battle cannot be won by anyone but Luke alone. Interfering in the physical fight could potentially be disastrous for the spiritual battle going on inside of Luke. If so, there’s no way that Obi-Wan would risk it.
Many fictional stories have inconsistencies to help the drama work out. To enjoy them you have to exercise a suspension of disbelief (as in intersteller space travel).
It’s not an inconsistency @YARNLADY. Obi-Wan was daid.
This is the correct answer:
Obi Wan taught Luke the Jedi skill of communicating with dead friends. Obi Wan had learned this newly discovered skill from Yoda at the end of Episode 3.
Presumably, if Luke used it in a fight with Vader, Vader could learn the skill, and communicate with dead Sith, which would be horrifying to the Rebel cause.
Wow. I don’t think I’ve ever seen any Starwars beyond the first one. Is there something wrong with me?
Answer this question