@cazzie I understand. I think one of the hardest things in life is living where you don’t like it very much, or longing for a place you used to live. NZ sounds like it has a very nice country culture. Plus, you were there when you were a young adult, and it was a positive experience, I think the timing maybe is important too.
I think you can see in my answers to you that I never assumed you hated America, just that you sometimes say hateful things about America, or things that didsappoint you. That’s different things. You are too far at a distance to know what America is really like day to day right now. You also had limited time only as a very young person here. We all have different perceptions when we are children or even very young adults. We aren’t our own person yet. We are at the mercy of others.
America puts place of birth on our passports too. Although, the passport doesn’t look any different for someone born in or outside the US. There are people born outside the US to American parents who never had to be naturalized, so where one is born doesn’t necessarily indicate the person was an immigrant.
If your son is interested in going to school in the US maybe read up on his right to be a citizen. Don’t take my information posted as the gospel obviously. Even if your husband won’t help you get a passport for him, maybe you can do something that makes sure he has citizenship. Right now I would assume America doesn’t even know he was born. If he can be a citizen he won’t have to do all that immigration paperwork for being a student, with possibilities of being rejected (although, that’s extremely unlikely being Norwegian). It would be way better if he did paperwork for being a citizen if he can. Then he can be a student as a citizen at citizen prices (some schools have international tuition prices) and he can work while attending school if he wants to. Student visas usually are non-working visas unless it has changed since my husband was here on a student visa.
It might matter if your son goes to the US before age 18. Maybe he can go as a minor and be in the custody of a family member or friend. In America he will be a minor, but most European countries and European people look at 16 as a significant age. I don’t know about Norway, but maybe your husband will see him more as a free agent at 17.
I still don’t know if Norway will make you formally renounce your American citizenship. Maybe I missed that in your answer. It sounds to me that the easiest thing is to mail in your paperwork on time to renew your American passport. If it has already expired then just don’t bother right now if you feel like you can’t do one more thing. Double check if how long you are expired matters for how difficult it is to renew.
You’ve been through a lot. Divorce, job change, you have a young child, and I’m sure a bunch of things we don’t even know about. For two years now I have felt like I don’t want to deal with one more change, obligation, or decision. I would guess you might be in the same state. I’ve been on edge, and I think you might be too. I’m projecting I realize. If it won’t matter if you wait to make the decision then maybe just wait. Give yourself a break.