Actually Family Guy is my answer as well. I remember a similar question some years ago and I said the same thing, can’t seem to find the question though. But I don’t know. I like The Simpsons, so people might think, why don’t you like Family Guy? I’ve not watched enough Family Guy to make an informed distinction however I think it’s safe to say that after seeing at least ten episodes, if I didn’t get into it then, I’m never going to. And I’ve seen different episodes from different seasons.
The humor is much too random, and although probably related it seems to me they just add things in there because they lack consistency and ideas. The thing about the dad disliking his daughter and picking on her and throwing soup in her face I don’t really enjoy either. I’m not offended by it or anything, kudos to the creator for making something a lot of folks enjoy. But it is not for me.
I much prefer American Dad because it’s closer to The Simpsons in humor and ideas, and although the dad and daughter don’t quite get along, I think it’s neat that they add a ruptured bond between them that fades as they both get older. It adds a reason to the concept, and makes the characters more likable. At least in this he doesn’t beat the crap out of her. It’s from the same creator, so you know he can do different things.
But Family Guy is like just a mash up of the most crude and offending stuff they can find to do, and it doesn’t work for me if it has no consistency or creativity. And that’s coming from me, who enjoys crude and offending stuff. But it needs to be done with a certain degree of intelligence, which besides finding cookie cutter plots centered around dysfunctional American families, Family Guy lacks. Simpsons are just as guilty really, and the last seasons suck but it has satire which I always enjoy, amd tons of references to so much trivia, which I like to try and find. After years and years of seeing the same episodes, I always find new stuff, like references to Ben Hur and such.
Although perhaps I am wrong about Family Guy, as we saw the baby, Stewie turn from a megalomaniac to a homosexual. (I think) It does show character development, just as it does in The Simpsons. But I cannot get into the humor, and also, the artwork I find unappealing. It really is just an issue of taste though, because I realize that many dislike The Simpsons while I totally love it.