Meta Question

Hawaii_Jake's avatar

Do you read the thread before answering?

Asked by Hawaii_Jake (37734points) April 26th, 2017

The title question usually requires a bit more information to be clear, and thus we have the details, which were asked about yesterday. However, there are some cases when full information doesn’t become apparent until the dialogue of the thread produces it. An OP will often add more information in the thread.

Sometimes further clarification is revealed by other answers that adds light to the subject in the thread.

When I enter a question with a meaty thread, I often read it entirely but not every time. There are times I only skim the answers to get the gist of the conversation. I usually will announce at the opening of my answer whether or not I’ve read all the details and the entire thread.

What do you do when you enter a question that has a thread? Do you simply answer the title question? Do you read the details carefully and skip the thread? Do you read everything? Do you skim it all?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

34 Answers

RedDeerGuy1's avatar

I have trouble reading the wall-o-text sometimes. I do my best to read the details.

SQUEEKY2's avatar

If the details are endless I tend to just skim them and from time to time that does get me into trouble, but most times I do try to read the whole question to get the angle the asker is coming from.

Hawaii_Jake's avatar

@SQUEEKY2 What about the thread? the answers?

canidmajor's avatar

I think you guys may be misunderstanding the Q. As I read it, @Hawaii_Jake is asking if we read the thread, not just the details, before answering.

I try to @Hawaii_Jake, unless it’s sort of a poll. The discussion is part of the fun for me.

Brian1946's avatar

Apparently some people don’t even bother reading the question itself. ;-o

I always read the thread, and I’m wondering if I’ll be the only one who answers the OP.

janbb's avatar

I usually read the thread but not necessarily every time. It sometimes depends on how interested I am in the whole discussion and sometimes just how quick I want to get my quip down.

SQUEEKY2's avatar

You’re right @canidmajor I did misunderstand what he was saying and for an answer I try to unless it’s a huge winded answer at which time my eyes glaze over and I usually skip those but for the most part yes I do read the thread(answers).

stanleybmanly's avatar

More often (too often) than not, I will answer the question then read through the thread. Redundancy

Earthbound_Misfit's avatar

It depends on the topic. Sometimes I do read to see what’s already been said to ensure I’m not just repeating what others have said. Sometimes I don’t want the influence of earlier answers and I answer off-the-bat and then read what other people posted. If it’s a long thread, and not an overly complicated topic, I may skim the thread and then answer.

Edit. I didn’t read the thread for this Q and just answered off-the-bat and now I’m seeing quite a few posts that suggest some people obviously don’t read the thread or the question in full :D

Kardamom's avatar

I usually read the full details, even if they’re long and involved, and I usually read the whole thread first.

Occasionally I will answer immediately for various reasons. Sometimes I’ll answer first, and read later if I have the exact answer that I want to give. I always mention that I’m answering first, and reading everyone else’s answers afterward, but I always read the details before answering.

Mimishu1995's avatar

I read the thread, but not as intensely as when I read the details. I usually skim the thread to get the general idea of the discussion and see if my idea has already been mentioned. I will stop to read everything in details when I see that the discussion isn’t what it’s supposed to be or is heated enough for an entertaining read. Otherwise I will just fastforward and only read the most interesting response.

Patty_Melt's avatar

I read the thread, but if it is some simple question like, “What do the clouds outside your window right now look like?” and an answer uses a bunch of hoity toity words, I skip it.
Sometimes a question needs a long detailed response, sometimes, “turtle” will suffice.

Strauss's avatar

Hoity-toity!

SimpatichnayaZhopa's avatar

Many questions have so amny answers that I do not have time to read them. I just answers questions generally. A gang of Lunatic Left brainwashed zombies is stalking and harassing me. They tell insulting lies about me. Thy should get a life and not spend so much time in harassment.

Mimishu1995's avatar

@SimpatichnayaZhopa ok, I’m going to respond to you for the last time. You fail to get people to agree with you then you get butthurt and say everyone is a zombie. And it’s funny you attack people, calling them “stalker”, “harasser”, “zombie”, then accuse people of telling lies about you. Everywhere you go you have to scream that you are that innocent person being harassed.

If you think we are not worth your time, then you can just delete your account and stay away from this site. The fact that your are complaining about the “zombies” attacking you everywhere you go shows that you also have a lot of time in your hand.

SimpatichnayaZhopa's avatar

Your gang os stalkers and harassers goes too far, much too far. Many times they have called me “Russian spy” and “Russian troll”. I hate Russia who invaded my homeland and made me a refugee. I only use this site once in a week or two. I am too busy the rest of the time. You all try to manufacture faults for me. Three os you have told me to leave, but you tyrants cannot force me to do anything. This is a free nation, and I have a right to disagree with your naïve brainwashed ideas. You leave if you are a tyrant telling me to leave. It is sad that your gang hates logic and objectivity so badly. Meet me in person and give me orders.

Mimishu1995's avatar

This is a free country right? Then everyone esle also has the right to disagree with your view. And everyone also has the right to ignore you at this point. You have done nothing other than calling everyone a tyrant and I’m sure everyone is tired of that now. You’re on your own now. I’m going to use my ignore right and won’t harass you any longer. Happy now? Bye.

canidmajor's avatar

Gosh, @SimpatichnayaZhopa we all are not involved in your issues here. In fact, you made no impression on me until you started ranting about being harassed and stalked. I have no doubt that people disagreed with you, but I doubt anyone “stalked” you. If we are notified when there is new activity on any question we are following (this one, for example), and people respond to other posters’ remarks, that does not mean people are “stalking”. If you have serious concerns about this, contact the mods and cite the places that you feel the ” gang of Lunatic Left brainwashed zombies” has specifically targeted you.

SimpatichnayaZhopa's avatar

Several people stalked me and called me “Russin spy” or “Russian troll” repeatedly. I hate Russia who invaded my homeland and made me a refugee. There is a gang constantly appearing on my notifications and telling insulting lies about me, e.g.. being a Russia spy, irrational, paranoid, etc. I have flagged many comments and they are removed. These people go too far. They hate people who disagree with them. Freedom has reasonable limits. Free speech does not cover slander, false accusations, lying insults, inciting riots or crimes, etc. I should have a right to answer all questions without being libeled. Conspiracy is a felony I hear.

canidmajor's avatar

Well, what you have described here does not remotely meet the criteria of “conspiracy”, nor is conspiracy, in and a f itself, a felony.
Like I said, contact the mods with specifics, and they can help you.

By the way, “libelous” also doesn’t apply here, unless your anonymity has been compromised and the accusations can be proved to affect you negatively (beyond upsetting you) like affecting your livelihood or safety.

If other users are sending you harassing private messages, contact the mods. If you think the posts from other users are grossly inappropriate, contact the mods.

But as you recognize that you have the right to disagree with some points of view, recognize that others have the right to disagree with you.

Calling people names is childish, and diminishes your credibility.

SimpatichnayaZhopa's avatar

They started calling me names and telling insulting lies, e.g. that I am a “Russian spy” or a “Russian troll”. Libelous intent is present. It se3ems to be a conspiracy with so many people telling the same insulting lies. Conspiracy to commit even a misdemeanor is a felony. You are not an attorney. They start trouble and accuse me of doing so. Someone said I am paranoid that is a type os insanity. Someone said I am irrational. ETC., ETC.!!!!!

canidmajor's avatar

Oh, dear. @SimpatichnayaZhopa, you are in no danger here, your lifelihood and/or personal safety are not endangered here. This is not libel, this does not constitute the legal definition of conspiracy. Your understanding of how the law works vis à vis anonymous Internet sites is flawed.

You do not know if any of us are or are not attorneys.

You need to calm down. If participating on this site is too stressful for you, you might want to rethink it.

I have given you good advice.

I frankly don’t care anymore.

SimpatichnayaZhopa's avatar

I know by experience that you all lie constantly just like the Lunatic Left Media that has brainwashed you. I believe nothing you say. Just go away.

SQUEEKY2's avatar

And @canidmajor you thought I was a challenge,bet you think I am just a big ole polar bear now, huh??^^

canidmajor's avatar

How’s your broken digit, @SQUEEKY2? Have you healed up?

SQUEEKY2's avatar

uh NO!I had to have surgery on it, now my whole arm is in a cast for the next five weeks,all for a broken little finger.

canidmajor's avatar

Oh dear! Well, I’m glad they fixed it, hopefully it’ll be better than ever by the time summer comes!

Mimishu1995's avatar

Hah… I think I understand what they mean by “stalking”. At one point some of us talked about their previous response on other threads to point out how they contradicted themselves. That’s probably their definition of stalking.

I’m sorry but it’s not remotely close to stalking. All the information we gathered from you came straight from the horse’s mouth. Everything you typed on here is visible to anyone coming to this site, not to mention search engine. You gave information about yourself consensually, then call anyone who repeats the same things you said a stalker.

You can’t walk into a party and shout “I still sleep with teddy bears at night” then get angry when days later someone says “hey is that you who still sleep with teddy bears at night?” If you are just here to make a fool out of us, you fail in so many levels.

Kardamom's avatar

Maybe one of the Mods would like to trot on over here and see what all the ruckus is about.

If @SimpatichnayaZhopa is in fact being “stalked” behind the scenes, then those people can be spoken too. If he/she is only complaining and doesn’t like the way this site works, then maybe the Mods can explain privately, and publicly, how the site does work.

So far, I haven’t seen any evidence of “public stalking”, just folks giving their opinions.

In the meantime, would anyone care for some Borscht?

SimpatichnayaZhopa's avatar

I spend my time here replying to cyberbullies and have no time to answer more questions. The attacks upon me are often savage. I have been called “Russian spy” and “Russian troll” many times. I hate Russia, so that is quite insulting. Some morons ridicule what I say. I demand that these trolls have civilized discussions and stop insulting me. You make fools of yourself quite well with no help.

Mimishu1995's avatar

OK, here’s the deal: you make a PM for the mods telling the names of every single person who “stalked” and “insulted” you and linking to the threads where they do such things to you and ask them to delete their accounts for you. If what you are saying is true, then all those people are clearly violating the rules of this site and they all deserve to be banned.

Do it for your own sake. You are a real sage and you don’t deserve all the harassment on your quest to enlighten the naive Left.

SimpatichnayaZhopa's avatar

I have reported the worst and had it removed.

Mimishu1995's avatar

As far as I can see they are still here.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther