What does "There is no there there" mean?
Asked by
flo (
13313data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/90eec/90eec35d07713703df557cec027f5fef4b82400a" alt="points"
)
May 11th, 2017
Observing members:
0
Composing members:
0
20 Answers
Yes, when someone says that there is nothing at a location. Like most of Kansas.
It means the place is desolate.
I don’t know if it is a legitimate use, but I have used the phrase to refer to a person who is lacking any core values, like Trump.
I heard it yesterday in passing from someone who could have been talking politics.
@LostInParadise I wouldn’t use it in that way. I would, however, use it to describe a stupid person.
As the link said, it is a quote of Gertrude Stein. It meant her childhood home was no longer.
It has been appropriated to mean there is no substance in a person, place, or thing.
@Hawaii_Jake Stupid in whose eyes though? The Trump people think that the anti Trump ones are stupid and vise versa.
@flo That’s up to each individual. I have ideas of what stupid means to me, and other people have their own definitions. We each get to decide.
@zenvelo has added something important. This quote is used to describe a lack of substance. That can be determined in many ways. It is possible for a very rich person to have little substance intellectually. It is also possible for someone to be very rich in personality but very poor monetarily.
@flo Of course it’s a statement of personal opinion and highly subjective. I don’t see what you are finding so hard to understand once it’s been defined quite well by the wiki article and others here.
Sounds a bit like what the definition if “is” is.
It may be legit but sounds bit strange.
Sheesh. I was working on something with There, they’re and their.
It’s a beautiful poetic summary of a sad realization.
You can never go back to there.
There is an ephemeral thing that only exists for a moment.
@LuckyGuy They’re there. It’s their there.
I’m sure I don’t know know.
The first time I encountered the phrase, it was on a postcard of a guy standing up to his ankles in ocean water at the beach looking at a map of Los Angeles. The point of that was that LA is incoherent and there is no definable center.
There’s an error. “They’re” should be “their.”
@Blueroses i like yours better.
@Blueroses I think you nailed it. Reminds me of a Beatles song: Golden Slumbers lyric “Once there was a way to get back home again…...” Ephemeral, poetic…
KANSAS IS THERE!!!
Sounds to me like they may have been discussing sentence structure.
Answer this question data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6ef99/6ef9935b4bc98727abd12a62124e0175d39dd885" alt="sending..."
This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.