What does "There is no there there" mean?
Asked by
flo (
13313)
May 11th, 2017
Observing members:
0
Composing members:
0
20 Answers
Yes, when someone says that there is nothing at a location. Like most of Kansas.
It means the place is desolate.
I don’t know if it is a legitimate use, but I have used the phrase to refer to a person who is lacking any core values, like Trump.
I heard it yesterday in passing from someone who could have been talking politics.
@LostInParadise I wouldn’t use it in that way. I would, however, use it to describe a stupid person.
As the link said, it is a quote of Gertrude Stein. It meant her childhood home was no longer.
It has been appropriated to mean there is no substance in a person, place, or thing.
@Hawaii_Jake Stupid in whose eyes though? The Trump people think that the anti Trump ones are stupid and vise versa.
@flo That’s up to each individual. I have ideas of what stupid means to me, and other people have their own definitions. We each get to decide.
@zenvelo has added something important. This quote is used to describe a lack of substance. That can be determined in many ways. It is possible for a very rich person to have little substance intellectually. It is also possible for someone to be very rich in personality but very poor monetarily.
@flo Of course it’s a statement of personal opinion and highly subjective. I don’t see what you are finding so hard to understand once it’s been defined quite well by the wiki article and others here.
Sounds a bit like what the definition if “is” is.
It may be legit but sounds bit strange.
Sheesh. I was working on something with There, they’re and their.
It’s a beautiful poetic summary of a sad realization.
You can never go back to there.
There is an ephemeral thing that only exists for a moment.
@LuckyGuy They’re there. It’s their there.
I’m sure I don’t know know.
The first time I encountered the phrase, it was on a postcard of a guy standing up to his ankles in ocean water at the beach looking at a map of Los Angeles. The point of that was that LA is incoherent and there is no definable center.
There’s an error. “They’re” should be “their.”
@Blueroses i like yours better.
@Blueroses I think you nailed it. Reminds me of a Beatles song: Golden Slumbers lyric “Once there was a way to get back home again…...” Ephemeral, poetic…
KANSAS IS THERE!!!
Sounds to me like they may have been discussing sentence structure.
Answer this question
This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.