“Did you ever get the feeling your parents don’t love you?”
No. Not for a second, not even when we were passionately angry with each other for various reasons. Lord knows I did enough things to make them disappointed in me, and they expressed that readily enough: disappointed in some foolish act or outcome, that is, but not really disappointed “in me”.
So I can’t quite identify, except…
My son has felt this way with me, I think. We’ve recently seemed to mend our relationship to a great degree, but it hasn’t been easy, and it has taken longer than I would have liked.
I came from a stable family. My parents had been together for fifty years at the time that they died within a few months of each other. On the other hand, I separated from my wife – my son’s and daughter’s mother – when they were in their late teens. At the time, my daughter was also having a rift with her mother, and my son felt a certain loyalty to his mother, so he went with her. (We hadn’t actually decided upon “a legal separation” or divorce or custody arrangements; we just did what seemed best at the time.) Neither of the kids know all of the interpersonal details between my wife and me that led to the separation – and in deference to her and to maintain a confidence that I believe any gentleman owes to his wife – I didn’t fill them in on all details, even though doing so would have made me look better than I did.
So my son spent a little over a year with my wife, who apparently felt a certain amount of betrayal and bitterness that she frequently expressed – to him – about me, and he came to resent me, but we never really talked about that. I don’t know the details that he heard, but I know that he held a lot of bitterness towards me over the fact of the separation, which greatly upset him.
Having been raised, myself, in a fairly non-demonstrative New England family of long standing tradition – that is, a long-standing tradition of “stiff upper lip” and a certain self-suppression of emotion (and affection) – it was difficult for me to reconcile with my son. And to compound things, he has been living mostly on the other side of the continent, so it’s more difficult to visit him and his family than it is to visit my daughter. So it took a long time to get over most of our difference and difficulties. I think we have managed, mostly, but it’s still difficult for me to maintain silence about some of the things about our marriage that could have changed his view of me more easily.
Let me ask you this (rhetorically), in light of all that: Is it possible that you harbor some resentment of your father based on the divorce, in which he removed himself (or “was removed”) from your life? If he were writing the question, would he use somewhat the same wording about you that you have used about him? That is, does he perceive that you may be silently judging him and finding him wanting? Are you disappointed in his behavior? Disappointed in his ability to move on and find happiness in a new family?
I’m not saying that you’re wrong about any of this – even if I knew you well enough to make the judgment it’s unlikely that I would ever express it so openly – but how do you suppose your father feels about the emotional gulf between the two of you? and Have you ever thought of asking him about it directly?