Social Question

RedDeerGuy1's avatar

Is it ok to drink caffeine free Diet Coke?

Asked by RedDeerGuy1 (24986points) December 18th, 2017

It says 0 calories. For mental health and dental health and other reasons?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

19 Answers

flameboi's avatar

Due to a number of factors (mostly heath concerns), recently I stopped drinking sugary/soft drinks, I quit eating highly processed foods (including eating out), and took a number of steps to clean out my diet from things like wheat pasta, white rice, white bread, that kind of thing. I also reduced the amount of meat/poultry to one portion a week of either of those. I also kept my one portion of fish a week. I did not quit milk, yogurt or cheese, however, I did reduce the portions to 4oz of milk, 4oz of yogurt and a slice of cheese a day. I do have nuts when I want a snack. It was the first time I actually cleaned my life so drastically. After 5 weeks I dropped a few pounds (without exercising much), my skin tone improved, I stopped losing my hair like crazy, and I began to sleep a lot better than I used to. I began to feel healthier, and it has been years since I felt that good.

Then, after about two months I had a small glass of coke just because I did not want to be rude (I had been served before my usual “just water, no ice please”)... After about 2 minutes I had to excuse myself because my body reacted as I had drank poison… I called my doctor in pain and he basically told me “once you stop drinking soft drinks, sugary drinks, or any highly processed foods for about a month or so, the moment you relapse you body will reject it, and depending on how sensitive you truly are to things like food additives or preservatives, it can be as bad as food poisoning”.

So, I felt bad for the whole afternoon/early evening. Over the next few of days I began testing a few things, and here is what happened…

I had a bag of crisps, plain Lays crisps, and felt like I had eaten a bag of rocks.

I had a bag of nachos, worst that the crisps.

I stopped by McDeath one night, and had a chicken sandwich, no mayo with a side of small fries, no ketchup, just mustard. It was just a few bites because it’s pretty small. I felt bloated and my stomach hurt for about 4 hours.

I pinched a panettone after a healthy breakfast of plain whole wheat toasts, lemon grass infusion, a green apple and a slice of cheese. Literally, it was just a pinch. It ruined my day, I could not have lunch because I felt so miserably bad.

During my testing week, I had very poor sleeping, sleeping no more than 5 hours each night. I felt restless and in general I was in a very crappy mood. And I had pimples like a teenager…

I resumed my eating habits and in just a couple of days I felt better again, sleeping pattern came back to normal, pimples were gone, and I assume my weight did not suffer the consequences.

It is very, very hard to drop those things. It is not the first time I have to clean up my act. It looks like my life derails every five years… I used to drink a bottle of coke every day when I was in my early 20s and from 120 pounds I managed to jump to 150 in about a year and a half. Then, when I quit smoking (I was in a pack a day mode) my weight again skyrocketed to almost 180 pounds. Then with diet and exercise it went back to 130. It stayed there for a while. While I was in grad school I did not have good eating habits, and my weight stayed low because i was eating poorly, so after I finished and began to eat like a normal person again my weight moved to about 180… I got in shape again to 140 but after a number of personal problems my life derailed again and I gained a lot of weight yet again and it jumped to 177… It has taken me months to lose a few pounds, and I’m still in the process of reaching a healthy weight to prevent future problems. I eat fruits and vegetables, grains, all that stuff (no magic juices, no wonder powders, just food).

I love coke, and fries, and crisps, and deep fried foods like any normal person (I lived in the south for a while too), I’d die for a good burger, and ice cream with oreos for dessert, but after having a long talk with myself, and remembering all the things my doctor have told me over the years, including the famous “you will not live to see 30”, I had to convince myself that, even though I love all those things, and I will always cherish my visit to the world of coke and how the polar bear bit my head, and tried all the varieties I could, and how I always asked for a good burger place everywhere I went, I had to stop. Not for the calories, or all the ingredients that sometimes are even hard to pronounce, I had to stop just to have a better quality of life, and age graciously…

So, for mental, and dental health, beyond the calories, give it a try and drink water. I’m sure your loved ones want to have you around for a very long time, which is another line my doctor used when he stopped by the hospital after a pretty bad scare many years ago.

This is me sharing a bit of my life, I’m not trying to rain on your parade, or anything like that. As I hit answer, I smile :)

filmfann's avatar

I have diabetes, and I drank diet coke regularly when I was first diagnosed.
I found that when I quit all sodas, my blood sugar numbers were easier to manage.
A friend told me that the body reacts to the sweeteners.

stanleybmanly's avatar

You know the answer to this. Have you ever met a health professional or nutritionist that recommended ANYTHING with Coke plastered on the container?

RedDeerGuy1's avatar

@stanleybmanly my dentist suggested me switch to caffeine and sugar free pop.

YARNLADY's avatar

Sugar free is probably better than regular, bot none is best. switch to flavored water.

Zaku's avatar

Just my experience:

I drunk a bunch of zero-calorie soda sweetened with sucralose (Splenda) for a couple of months and ended up with the only kidney stone I’ve ever had. One of the most unpleasant experiences I’ve had. They analyzed it after it came out, and the doctor wasn’t sure but thought it was possibly related to that soda consumption. I have avoided sucralose and more than very rare/occasional soda since, and have not had any more kidney stones.

Now I drink a lot of water. I also mix about ⅓ to ¼ Trader Joe apple juice with the rest Trader Joe fizzy water, and I’ve been really enjoying that.

stanleybmanly's avatar

@RedDeerGuy1 I stand corrected. If the choice must be either the standard red can or the caffeine free chemical concoction, follow your dentist’s council. Over the years I’ve often wondered whether or not you pay any attention to the myriad of folks participating in your care. Do you have a Christmas tree?

MrGrimm888's avatar

Isn’t the carbonic acid, in sodas, bad for your teeth also?...

rojo's avatar

@Zaku good to know,
I have been plagued with stones in the past and have been drinking the sweetened carbonated water drinks from the grocery store thinking that I was getting plenty of fluids through my system. Now I have something else to worry about. Might have to switch permanently to tap water and lemon concentrate, my fall back drink of choice.

Darth_Algar's avatar

I would recommend anyone with mental health issues avoid Diet Coke or anything containing aspartame. It can fuck with neurotransmitters. Besides, sugar is not the only thing in sodas that can harm your teeth. The acids in soft drinks (which will be there whether your Coke is regular or diet) can be extremely corrosive to teeth.

A better idea is to just drink regular soda if you must drink them (I get, I’m addicted too) but cut back on your consumption and practice better dental hygiene.

RedDeerGuy1's avatar

@stanleybmanly No I don’t have a Christmas tree. Im not Christian anymore. Bullyed by chrstain kids and teachers from the Catholic seperate school system in Canada . And want very little to do with them. Did the belief o matic quiz online and it says that I am a secular humanist.

Dutchess_III's avatar

I tried drinking caffeine free Diet Coke. It’s just nasty! So I just quit drinking Coke altogether (almost) and switched to diet Sprite. And strawberry Pedialyte.

I’m not a Christian any more either, but I still decorate for the holidays. It just brightens up the house during the gloomy winter days.

stanleybmanly's avatar

many secular humanists indulge themselves with Christmas trees.

RedDeerGuy1's avatar

@stanleybmanly I have the fireplace channel. Its good enough for now.

si3tech's avatar

@RedDeerGuy1 I only drink sugar free pop when I drink pop. There is caffeine free too if you want to avoid both caffeine and sugar.

MollyMcGuire's avatar

OK with whom? Do you really need permission and approval for your diet?

josie's avatar

pH of Diet Coke – 3.3

pH of Stomach acid -3.3

Tooth enamel dissolves at pH 5.5

Give it up

Rarebear's avatar

It is safe to eat or drink any food in moderation.

SergeantQueen's avatar

Based on your questions on this site, I can tell you struggle with very bad anxiety. I do as well.
I have a really bad eating habit. I eat whenever I’m bored, tired, stressed. I’ve found that the more unhealthy/sugary junk food/sodas that I eat or drink, The more panic attacks I have and the worse they get. This could just be a personal thing for me, but I’ve been trying to give up soda, coffee, and unhealthy foods in general. I’ve had like 5 panic attacks this month, and before that, that last one I had was like 2 or 3 years ago. So I’m trying to figure out what’s going on. And my eating habits have been the first thing I’m changing.

As other people are saying on here though, you can eat or drink anything as long as you don’t go to crazy

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther